When I read the original letter to the editor, I almost expected the Saugus High School yearbook to be like something from HBO’s late-night line-up:
“This past week, my 16-year-old daughter came home with her school yearbook. As I was looking through it, I came across the ‘Dating Page.’ On the dating page, larger than all other photos on the page, is a photo of two girls kissing. The caption reads, ‘A Simple Kiss — (Girl’s name) and her girlfriend (other girl’s name) are not afraid to express their love for each other on campus.”
My imagination took that ball and ran with it. I forwarded a copy of the letter to the newsroom, with instructions that we should look into this matter and see if it’s something that has — or will — cause an uproar.
Without seeing the picture, it’s easy to envision some kind of a passionate lesbian liplock, something that would at least rate PG-13, which of course for some of our more conservative local folks might as well be an NC-17.
So we looked into it. Our intrepid journalists tracked down a copy of the yearbook, opened it to the “dating” page, and found...
A peck on the cheek.
Is that IT?
I found it difficult to see that particular kiss as something that would spark much controversy. Heck, there were barely any sparks flying in the kiss.
If it wasn’t accompanied by the caption, and wasn’t placed in the context of a “dating” page, you might not even conclude the two girls were gay.
We decided not to make a big deal out of it with a news story, but we went ahead and ran the letter, along with a clarifying editor’s note — it wasn’t a photo of “two girls kissing.” It was a photo of one girl kissing the other girl’s cheek.
We are, of course, all about getting the facts, er, straight.
What followed — and still follows — has been a pretty interesting, sometimes heated exchange of letters to the editor. We’ve gotten letters from people who, like the first letter writer, were offended that the yearbook included mention of same-sex relationships on campus and comments from an “openly gay” male student. We’ve also gotten letters defending the yearbook, and standing up for acceptance of different sexual orientations among the student body.
I won’t get into the psychology of it all. The teen years are a turbulent time. Who am I to say whether these kids have figured out their sexual identities yet, or if this is teenage rebellion and experimentation?
But it does raise the question of excessive public displays of affection. The younger you are, the more prone you are to it — gay, straight, whatever. And the older you get, the more you realize how uncomfortable it can be for those around you. That’s why my wife and I stopped making out at restaurants a year or two ago.
OK. It was longer ago than that. Cripes she’s going to kill me when she reads this.
Anyway. I wasn’t at all offended by the lesbian peck on the cheek in the Saugus yearbook, nor did I find any of the photos of straight couples offensive. But I guarantee you, if you visit any high school during the passing period between classes, or at the end of lunch, you’ll get an eyeful.
They’re young. They’re passionate. Hormones, running a thousand miles an hour. And now that I’m older — and a parent — I wish they’d stop doing that in public.
This all demonstrates just how much the cliché applies at my alma mater: The more things change, the more they stay the same.
We’ve had various pendulums swinging in opposite directions the past two decades. Teenagers still clutch, grab and smooch publicly in ways that make adults squirm.
But there are big differences, too. In my days at Saugus High, there was actually a smoking area on campus — for students — and an “openly gay” male student would have been doing well to make it home safely every day, much less make statements in the yearbook about same-sex relationships.
And, I can tell you with certainty, we never had girls kissing each other at Saugus High School when I was there.
I’d remember that.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager. His column appears Sundays in the opinion section and Tuesdays on page A2.
