A Santa Clarita mother who took her 4-year-old daughter to the library for a learning experience was outraged by pornography on a computer screen in plain view of her child, she said Wednesday.
But county library officials said they can do nothing to halt such uses of library computers because visitors have a First Amendment right to view pornographic material.
Lorrie Holguin said the incident last week was doubly offensive, because the computer in question was just 10 feet or so from the children’s section in the Canyon Country Library.
Holguin said she had escorted her daughter to play games on the computer when she “noticed the man sitting next to us was viewing very graphic, harsh pornography.”
“I was absolutely horrified!” she wrote in a letter to Santa Clarita Mayor Cameron Smyth.
Holguin said she immediately approached library officials and was told by a worker at the information desk that there were no restrictions on computer content.
“The children have to walk by the computers to get to their section,” Holguin said.
Nancy Mahr, spokeswoman for the county public library system, said staff members cannot stop visitors from using computers to view pornography.
“We do try to place (the computers) in fairly public areas for staff to view them,” Mahr said.
If staff members see someone viewing pornography, they may approach the individual and remind him or her that libraries are public places. But they cannot stop the person from viewing the material, Mahr said.
“It is a First Amendment issue,” she said. “The Supreme Court ruled that they have the right to view what they want ... as long as it is not illegal,”
To control content would be censorship, she said.
Canyon Country head Librarian Susan Broman said the dilemma is trying to avoid censorship while protecting children.
The library currently has 15 computers, four of them in the children’s section.
Privacy screens are being installed on the computers to prevent people from viewing each other’s screens, she said, but the process is not due to be complete until next week.
Anyone who holds a library card and signs an agreement is able to use a library computer.
The agreement states that the user will be responsible and not use the computer for business.
Adults can opt to have a filter installed on their accounts, and parents may have filters installed for their children’s Internet accounts.
Filters are software programs aimed at blocking inappropriate material.
Mahr said she would have encouraged Holguin to move to the computers in the children’s section to show her daugher how to play games.
“We encourage parents and children to use the children’s computers,” Mahr said.
She added: “The library serves a variety of outlooks and lifestyles. We provide (the computer service) free of charge without censorship.”
But Holguin was unsatisfied with the library’s response to the situation.
“We will not be going back,” she said.
