From the frying pan into the fire, the College of the Canyons board is finding new and ever more interesting ways to make news. Fresh off the Vital Express debacle, the board has called a special meeting Wednesday so it can slap one of its own five members for opening his mouth.
I didn’t attend last week’s board meeting so I don’t know the details, but you know how this town is. Somebody tells somebody who tells somebody, and pretty soon the truth is distorted all out of proportion.
What we know is that COC board member Ron Gillis thought the college was paying too much for property in Canyon Country for a satellite campus.
What we’ve heard through the grapevine is that Gillis is basing his complaints on the idea that there were two appraisals on the Sierra Highway property. Supposedly one came in at $5 million and another at $6.5 million — and the college is purchasing the property for the higher price.
Again, I don’t know what’s true and what isn’t.
And attending last Wednesday’s meeting would have put me no closer to the truth. Real-estate negotiations are discussed behind closed doors. I wouldn’t have been privy to the “closed session” information.
We may never know what went into the decision to pay what may have been the higher price. The college board certainly doesn’t want anybody to know, because it has scheduled a special meeting in the COC cafeteria Wednesday at 5:30 p.m. for the specific purpose of censuring Gillis for divulging the information — whether his claims were right or wrong.
The board plans to throw the book at him — literally. They’re using a provision of the California code book dealing with the disclosure of “confidential information.”
Not a lawyer, I don’t know whether an appraisal of property being purchased by a government agency is or isn’t confidential.
But to the extent that it might be, the college board is accusing Gillis of violating Section 54963(a) of the Government Code, which says:
“A person may not disclose confidential information that has been acquired by being present in a closed session authorized by Section 54956.7, 54956.8, 54956.86, 54956.87, 54956.9, 54957, 54957.6, 54957.8, or 54957.10 to a person not entitled to receive it, unless the legislative body authorizes disclosure of that confidential information.”
Section 54956.8 is the one that deals with real-estate transactions.
All of these code sections are part of the Ralph M. Brown Act, colloquially known as the state’s “open meeting” law, which basically says the public is entitled to know what its government agencies are doing, with a few narrow exceptions — such as the nuances of real-estate negotiations.
While the negotiations are under way, that is. Once the deal is done, elected officials generally have the right to complain about them.
That’s how this layman interprets other subdivisions of the same code section.
To wit, Section 54963(c)(2) says a legislative body can’t take disciplinary measures if somebody is “expressing an opinion concerning the propriety or legality of actions taken by a legislative body of a local agency in closed session, including disclosure of the nature and extent of the illegal or potentially illegal action.”
Section 54963(c)(3) also precludes disciplinary action “under the whistleblower statutes contained in Section 1102.5 of the Labor Code...”
Whistleblowers are usually employees, not elected members of a legislative body, but you get the idea: The law seeks to protect people’s First Amendment right to express their views.
If a dissenting board member can’t complain about an action taken in closed session, think of all the things a legislative body — a college board, the City Council, the Board of Supervisors — could do, without the voters ever being the wiser.
I don’t know if the college is paying too much for its east campus. I don’t know anything about Ron Gillis’ motives for saying so. But it seems to me that slapping somebody for doing his job as an elected official — representing his constituents and calling it like he sees it — might not be the wisest approach.
If there’s a $1.5 million dispute in the purchase price of some property, and rumors are flying around the way they always do in this town, you’d think the college would want to hold an open and thorough discussion to assure the public it’s doing the right thing and nobody on either side of the property transaction is unduly benefiting. After all, it’s not the board’s money. It’s yours.
The irony is, if the college hadn’t scheduled Wednesday’s meeting, the whole thing probably would have died quietly without ever becoming an issue.
The bigger irony is, COC board members don’t usually put things on their meeting agenda unless there is “consensus” that the item should be discussed. When did they get together and agree to agendize Gillis’ censure? If they did it over the phone, that’s called a “serial meeting,” and under the Brown Act it’s patently illegal.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s opinion and multimedia editor. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily The Signal’s.
