For David Colin, the Sept. 11 event he attended held mixed emotions.
In one sense, he was a member of the local community, and of the national community, which were affected by the terrorist attacks.
But he also belonged to another, smaller group, whose individual loss cannot be compared to the collective nation’s feelings about the tragedy.
Colin’s brother Robert worked for an insurance company on the 92nd floor of the south tower of the World Trade Center. Robert Colin was one of roughly 3,000 people who lost their lives in the attacks.
David Colin sat at a table at Elks Lodge 2379 on Sierra Highway Wednesday evening sharing apple pie with his 17-month-old grandson Aiden and talked about the first anniversary of the attacks and how the day affected him.
“It’s harder than I thought it was going to be,” he said.
Colin, a member of the lodge, was asked to speak at the lodge’s Sept. 11 commemoration event, which in some ways resembled a normal barbecue, in some ways a typical lodge dinner and in some ways another component of the community’s collective dealings with the anniversary.
“I loved my brother very much,” Colin told the group, showing a news report that talked about a subject most people didn’t have to deal with in the aftermath of Sept. 11, 2001.
It talked about Robert Colin’s funeral, about how no one would share any details with the family concerning where or when his remains were found, and about how information regarding the victims was hard to come by after the attacks.
David Colin wasn’t the only one in the room who had personal ties.
Lodge member Ken Lyon’s nephew, Lt. Glen Wilkenson of the New York Fire Department, also died when the twin towers collapsed.
Lyon chose not to speak to the audience, but lodge member Tom Schmidt read a eulogy for Wilkenson in his place.
The event included awards and speeches; essay contest winners shared their work about what the flag meant to them.
Later, attendees held a candlelight vigil while local Boy Scouts “retired” tattered flags by burning them.
Somehow the national tragedy meshed with the personal tragedy at the lodge, as those who merely watched and listened were for a moment privy to at least a small part of the grief shared by those who lost friends and family members in the attacks.
And for a moment, the day meant more than celebrations and bold displays of patriotism, more than flag waving and boisterous renditions of “The Star Spangled Banner.”
For a moment, the real loss of the Sept. 11 attacks manifested itself in two families whose grief was greater than a nation’s.
