Don’t we all wish our property values could jump like this? Check out the numbers on “Property No. 6,” one of seven pieces of a real estate puzzle College of the Canyons is assembling to build a second campus in Canyon Country:
October Appraisal: $2 million
November Appraisal: $1.38 million
February Appraisal: $2.27 million
June Appraisal: $6.45 million
Actual Sales Price: $6.25 million
I’ll be the first to admit I’m no real estate expert. But from this layman’s perspective, it seems like there should have been something COC could have done to avoid the value of the property tripling from the beginning of negotiations to the close of escrow.
James Schrage, the college’s dean of physical plant and facilities planning, says he wishes there was.
“The public agency is at a huge disadvantage in any property acquisition,” he said this week.
On its face, it appears COC paid $4 million more than it should have. College officials insist they actually got a pretty good deal under the circumstances.
The value started to edge up once it became known COC was sniffing around “Property No. 6” and the adjoining parcels. Even properties that weren’t part of the deal experienced a bump in values, due to the planned campus, which would be a significant upgrade to the neighborhood.
Then, COC began negotiating, based on appraised values of the property, which hovered around $2 million. The owners, trustees of the Rice family trust, wanted more.
They knew COC needed the property to build the campus. They had secured an offer from a developer (contingent upon development entitlements) for more than $6 million.
They also must have known COC couldn’t walk away — it had removed any contingency from the purchases it completed for adjoining properties.
In other words, COC had no leverage.
I’ve heard the explanations, but I still can’t understand why they removed the contingencies, which at least would have allowed them the option of saying: “Offer it at a lower price, or we walk.” It’s a poker thing.
When it came to price, Schrage says the college’s hands were tied because of laws governing the way public agencies have to negotiate. Once the “condemnation-level” appraisal came in, the college was stuck paying that price — or more, if it had to pursue an eminent domain seizure — unless the seller offered the land at a lower price.
The seller, Schrage says, held all the cards once the “eminent domain-level” appraisal came in at $6.45 million.
“It’s ‘game over’ and I think that needs to be said,” Schrage said. “We’re not under the same rules as private individuals.”
An observer who’s not connected to the negotiations might wonder if something smells fishy about the whole deal: A property is worth $2 million when a deep-pocket public agency inquires to buy, and by the time the deal is consummated, the price is driven up to $6.25 million after the agency gives up its contingency “hammer” and the seller secures a competing offer at an apparently inflated price.
COC officials insist that’s not the case; that they were bound by rules that are unfavorable to public agencies negotiating property deals. I would agree, on its face, that the rules of the game seem unfairly slanted against an entity like COC, acting in the taxpayers’ behalf. Further, when I asked these questions of Schrage and other COC officials this week, the answers seemed plausible and logical.
But I still can’t help wondering: Isn’t there some way COC could have prevented the price from tripling in four months?
Anyone?
* * *
From $2 million to $6 million in 8 months
The following information is from the timeline released at the College of the Canyons board of trustees meeting Aug. 24:
July 2004
* Site brought to college’s attention
October 2004
* Appraisal No. 1 received, $2 million
* Potential offer discussed with owner, second appraisal requested
November 2004
* Appraisal No. 2 received, $1.38 million
December 2004
* Offer submitted, expires, no counter-offer
January 2005
* Third appraisal requested
February 2005
* Appraisal No. 3 received, $2.27 million
March 2005
* Owner makes counter-offer: $6.25 million; college lets counter-offer expire
* Owner receives appraisal: $8 million
April 2005
* College receives notice from owner’s counsel of competing offer: $6.25 million
* College requests “condemnation-level appraisal” No. 4
June 2005
n Appraisal No. 4 received: $6.45 million
July 2005
* July 7: Board requests independent review of appraisal No. 4; college offers $5 million
* July 10: Offer expires, no counter-offer
* July 13: A second $5 million offer
* Mid-July: Independent review of appraisal No. 4 disagrees with some of appraiser’s conclusions, concludes value is $5 million
* July 20: Owner makes counter-offer, $6.25 million; offer accepted
August 2005
* Aug. 10: Board confirms purchase on 4-1 vote at $6.25 million
* Aug. 24: Escrow closes
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager.
