Most everyone agreed after the most expensive City Council election in Santa Clarita history that local campaign finance reform was needed. The problem: no one can agree what exactly is the best solution.
The council nixed a proposal Tuesday night that would have limited the amount individuals can contribute to political action committees during city elections. Instead, a majority of the members said more information is needed before any changes are made to the city’s election laws.
Councilman Cameron Smyth called for election reform after tens of thousands of out-of-state donations poured into local PAC war chests just days before the April 9 election. Smyth was elected in April 2000 and will seek re-election in 2004.
More than $72,000 was spent by PACs in the election, figures show.
The initiative would have limited individual contributions to PACs to $250 per committee per contest. It was defeated 3 - 2.
“I still hold true to my belief that we need to make some changes here,” Smyth said.
And no one on the 5-member panel is disputing that statement.
“I support the concept Cameron was going for,” Councilman Bob Kellar said. “Our election procedures need to be reviewed and improved upon. Clearly, money from outside Santa Clarita had an impact on the election and everyone is disturbed by that.”
Kellar, who is also up for re-election in 2004, was one of the dissenters of Smyth’s initiative. He said changing the city law wouldn’t have helped stave off the influx of donations because the money came from PACs registered with the state, not the city.
“We can make changes to anything local, but it won’t make a difference, he said.
Besides the $250 ceiling on individual contributions, the city doesn’t have a limit on how much individuals can give to PACs. That’s what Smyth wanted to change, saying the initiative would send a message.
“If somebody wants to impact an outcome of a city election, they’re not going to care about a message,” Kellar responded.
Some council members suggested the city follow the state standards.
California election laws don’t limit the amount a company can give to a state-registered PAC, which is sometimes referred to as “soft money.” However, it does limit individual contributions to $1,000 per candidate per contest.
Councilwoman Marsha McLean called Smyth’s amendment to the city code “empty.”
“Some people thought this was going to solve all the problems,” McLean said. “It’s not even a tiny little baby step. It’s a no step.”
April’s election was McLean’s third attempt at a council seat when she finished in second place. McLean raised roughly $17,000 in that election cycle.
Top vote-getter Mayor Frank Ferry out fund-raised all 12 candidates topping off at $75,000 in individual contributions, nearly doubling money from the next closest fund raiser.
Asked if stocking his coffers with that much money was a bit excessive for a City Council election, Ferry said the cost of running a successful campaign is steadily increasing.
“The reality between rising costs and rising people you have to contact, there is no fixed price in running a campaign anymore,” said Ferry, who held eight fund-raisers over the course of a year anticipating an expensive run. “I’m going to put the energy and time it takes to earn the money.”
Ferry said local elected water and school board officials fall under the umbrella of state laws, and the city should follow suit.
But Ferry and McLean both were beneficiaries, whether welcomed or not, of the unlimited PAC spending.
McLean said limiting city political committees would impair local the grass-roots groups that don’t register with the state.
“We need to figure how to level the playing field in a way that is going to be effective for everyone,” she said. “I want the grass-roots (candidates) to have the same chance as other candidates.”
Show me the money
At issue is the $32,000 spent by Waste Management Inc. in the last days of the election. Waste Management, parent company to local trash haulers Blue Barrel Disposal and Santa Clarita Disposal, cut a $20,000 check to Action for Better Government, a PAC run by local developer consultant Allan Cameron.
Cameron, in turn, spent the money on three candidates: Ferry, McLean, and former mayor Jan Heidt, who finished fourth in the contest.
Another $12,000 was doled out by the trash company to pay for mailers and phone bank efforts on behalf of Ferry and McLean.
The strange coincidence to some was Waste Management was in the few weeks leading up to the election seeking to retain its $135 million trash contract with the city. Some thought the funding targeted “Waste Management friendly” candidates even though the council voted 3-2 on March 26, two weeks before the election, to put the lucrative contract out to competitive bid, making the nation’s No. 1 trash hauler reapply for the job.
Both McLean and Heidt said during the election they supported a public bidding process for the contract.
Ferry recognized the irony.
“The issue becomes what is good PAC money versus bad PAC money,” Ferry said.
PAC expenditure reports figures show Ferry received more than $23,154 in — mailers, phone banking, etc. — from four separate groups, while McLean received $17,946 from three groups. Heidt followed with $11,065, then Weste with $3,975.
He added that the issue isn’t always black and white when it comes to committee spending.
“Any candidate that receives tens of thousands from one source should be scrutinized,” Ferry said. “We wear it out on our sleeve. I know I’m going to be scrutinized.”
But Waste Management wasn’t the only company to shell out the dough.
Local developers either contributed to PACs or created their own in an attempt to sway the election.
Landowner Larry Rasmussen spent nearly $4,000 on Councilwoman Laurene Weste, who placed third. Rasmussen also gave thousands to Action for Better Government and BUCK PAC, which is affiliated with U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon.
Weste, who was the second vote favoring Smyth’s initiative, told the council that if the city is able to control spending in its election that is a positive first step.
“(The initiative) lets you close one loophole now,” she said. “I know my money is as good as my neighbors.”
Weste said she recognized that more PACs would turn to state reporting, but said the change wasn’t an “end all, be all” to the city’s campaign issues.
Developer Jack Shine, PacSun LLC, the company that is building Golden Valley Ranch, and Remediation Financial Inc., owner of the Porta Bella property, also contributed thousands to the three main PACs — Action for Better Government, Citizens for Responsible Government and BUCK PAC — which supported Ferry, McLean and Heidt.
Next move
Smyth said he will listen to his fellow council members to decide what the next move will be.
“Unless the council is prepared to make fundamental changes, we’re limited in options in alternatives we can seek,” Smyth said.
Ferry, however, does agree with Smyth saying today is the time to change the election code, with enough time for candidates seeking office in 2004 to plan.
“Right now is the time to make sure its a fair process for everyone,” Ferry said.
Several council member suggested to hold public symposiums to find out how residents and business owners gauge campaign spending.
Now matter what is decided, Smyth said the responsibility lays solely on the council.
“This is a decision we should make. We shouldn’t abdicate our responsibility to the public,” Smyth said about holding a special election to let the Santa Clarita voters decide.
Ferry said the council is in a Catch-22 position saying if the council prohibits spending that could potentially impact one or two groups, it will look like the council is trying to keep out a certain candidate. However, the council needs to protect the city from outside influences, he said.
“No matter what we do, it looks like we’re making up the rules to our benefit,” Ferry said.
Smyth said making rules is the council’s job.
“Ultimately, the council should be able to make a decision like this. The easy thing is to take it out of the council’s hand. We were elected to do the hard things,” Smyth said.
