It’s a fender-bender tale, but stick with me on this — I’m going somewhere with it.
I was driving my wife’s car, a little red Honda that, compared to the truck I usually drive, feels like a zippy go-cart. It’s tough to look like much of a tough guy, driving a little red Honda.
I forget why my wife had my usual ride that day, but she had the crew-cab truck with the gas-guzzling V-8 and the dual, growling exhaust. I had the “cute” car. At least she’s removed the Minnie Mouse ears antenna topper.
I pulled into the driveway of The Signal. I stopped and waited while a car pulled out from our customer parking. The woman backed up... and backed up... and backed up...
It became clear she didn’t see me back there, in my cute little Honda. I reached for the horn, but the Honda’s horn isn’t in the same place as it is on my truck. On the truck, you just mash the center of the wheel and you hear a satisfying “HONK!”
On the Honda, there’s a pair of cute little buttons, one on each side of the wheel, and you tap them with your finger — cripes, probably a pinkie — and you get an apologetic, “Beep!”
Since the buttons weren’t where I expected them to be, it took that extra split second to find them and honk. The woman backing out of her parking spot didn’t hear me in time.
Her car tapped mine.
It wasn’t what you’d call a major collision. But I figured there was a pretty good chance one or both of us had bumper damage. I assumed she’d pull forward a few feet so we could swap information.
But she didn’t do that. She started to drive off. When I became certain she had no intention of stopping, I honked again — and now, I knew where those beep-beep buttons were. I stood on them both with my thumbs.
She finally stopped and got out of her car. I said I was surprised she was trying to drive away after hitting me.
“Oh I barely tapped you,” she said, disdain oozing from every word.
True, it wasn’t much of a collision. But these days, it doesn’t take much. A couple of bumpers collide at 3 mph and you’ve got $8,000 in damage.
I agreed it wasn’t a big deal, but I thought she may have done a little damage to my wife’s bumper and we should swap insurance information.
“Fine,” she said, “then I’ll just go back into The Signal and take back that $100 check I just gave for the Katrina victims.”
What the...?
She said she didn’t see me because she was preoccupied, worrying about the victims who were impacted by the monster hurricane that flooded New Orleans. She had visited The Signal to drop off the check (we’ve been collecting for the Red Cross).
She couldn’t have been as worried as she said. After all, she was willing to go take back her check because she was ticked off at being held responsible for a parking lot love tap.
The lady and I argued for a minute. I was worried about the Katrina victims, too, but I don’t think it’s an excuse for hit-and-run driving.
I called my wife. I described the apparent damage, which upon inspection seemed extremely minor at worst. We agreed to write if off, and let the woman leave without giving me her insurance information.
The Red Cross got to keep her hundred bucks.
That incident, and a few conversations I’ve had in the past couple of weeks, got me thinking about the reasons people give, and the attitudes some people have about it.
A colleague asked me: “All the Katrina donations coming in from corporations and wealthy individuals — how much of it is genuine, from-the-heart giving and how much is ‘cause’ marketing, designed to make the contributor look good, and thereby make people buy more of the contributor’s product, because the people think the formerly despicable contributor ain’t so bad after all?”
Fair question.
As I said, we have been collecting for the Red Cross, and I like the way we’ve done it. We haven’t required any purchase. People can drop by, leave a check, and they don’t have to subscribe or anything like that. We’re just giving people a location option for convenient donations. Yes, we’re giving credit to the donors — but the upshot is, it’s a simple collection drive.
The question: Aside from my bumper bender lady and others who view making a donation as an excuse to behave badly, are there people or businesses contributing in order to offset bad behavior, or maybe to drum up business?
This is kind of a “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” scenario for some businesses, especially large corporations: Establish a relief fund to collect (and/or make) donations, and get accused of “cause marketing.”
Do nothing — or do something without telling the public about it — and get accused of being uncaring about your fellow man.
It’s either, “Oh, look at them, they’re just trying to boost their image,” or it’s, “Oh look at them — big fat-cat company doesn’t give a rat’s patoot about the poor victims.”
I’d rather err on the side of helping.
Some of what we’ve seen is obviously “cause marketing.” When a business says, “Come buy your widget here, and we’ll donate the proceeds (or, in fine print, a ‘portion’ of the proceeds)...” — well, it’s hard not to be a little cynical about the motives.
If nothing else, the “cheese factor” varies a great deal among all of the myriad ways you can donate to help the victims. At one extreme are the folks and companies that just give quietly, studiously avoiding fanfare. At the other extreme are those trying to turn a quick buck on the coattails of public sympathy for storm victims.
When all is said and done, of course, the most important thing is getting aid effectively to the people who’ve suffered the most — food, water, medicine, clothing, shelter. So long as we get these basics to those impacted by the storm, a donor’s motivation doesn’t matter so much.
As I write this, Hurricane Rita is bearing down on the Texas coast and the new storm’s outer fringes are dumping just enough rain on New Orleans to start re-flooding the already Katrina-ravaged city.
It all serves as a reminder: There are a lot of people with much bigger problems on their hands than a parking lot fender bender.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager. His column appears Sundays in the opinion section and Tuesdays on page A2.
