All five City Council members claim to be in favor of some kind of reform for the campaign financing in local council elections. Only two have demonstrated it with their actions.
It’s unfortunate, but it appears — so far — that the other three are only paying lip service to the issue. The council’s handling of it Tuesday night could easily lead one to believe this is the sort of item that will result in the council forming one of those committees politicians enjoy forming: They’ll study the issue to death, interminably, and in the end they’ll either do nothing or adopt a measure that is so watered down as to be completely ineffective.
This is one of those instances in which we hope, desperately, that we’re wrong. We hope, desperately, that the three members who voted “no” will back up their statements with actions — and move swiftly forward to adopt meaningful reform that levels the playing field and helps keep our supposedly “hometown” City Council campaign costs from spiraling out of control.
We desperately hope that Marsha McLean, Frank Ferry and Bob Kellar are better than their votes of Tuesday night seem to indicate. We desperately hope that, when they said they favor campaign reform — but just not this reform — they were speaking from just one side of their mouth before casting those “no” votes.
The proposal they rejected — put forth by Councilman Cameron Smyth and supported by Councilwoman Laurene Weste — would have been a simple, principled attempt to make the same rules apply to everyone. Currently, each individual is allowed to contribute up to $250 to the campaign of a candidate during an election cycle. Even with that limit, several candidates — including Smyth and Ferry — have found they are able to build war chests in the $50,000 range (for a part-time job that pays little more than $1,000 a month).
However, there’s a loophole that allows big, moneyed interests to get around the $250 limit: Contributions to political action committees are not limited at all, so a single donor can contribute as much as he, she or it wants to a PAC.
That’s exactly what happened in the April election, when Houston-based Waste Management Inc. — seeking to buy votes in its favor for the city’s trash contracts — spent more than $30,000 through PACs to support the campaigns of Ferry, McLean and Jan Heidt.
Smyth’s plan was a simple, even-handed proposal that, admittedly, would not solve every campaign finance issue. But it would have been a fine start — and Ferry, Kellar and McLean said no.
A cynic might think that’s because they wish to keep the big money flowing, or because they’re bowing to the wishes of moneyed interests. We desperately hope that’s not the case. The trio who sent Smyth’s proposal down in flames say they favor meaningful campaign reform. Now, we have just one request:
Prove it.
