ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Pranks, Shenanigans, Hazing and Phases

Boys will be boys.

And, typically, what happens in the locker room, stays in the locker room — but that mostly unspoken “code” goes out the window when something crosses “The Line.”

Exactly where is The Line?

It can be drawn at many different points. It can depend on the time, the circumstances, local community standards, the individuals involved, whether Mercury is in retrograde...

I remember one day after a high school football practice, a little over two decades ago, when our team was starting to shower.

The showers at Saugus High back then took a while to warm up, if they did at all. (Are they any better now, guys?) A few of the guys had started their showers, and the water was still cold.

One of them felt something warm running down the back of his leg.

Yes, it was what you think.

At the time, no one thought that the prank, played by a teammate, had crossed The Line. The guy who had been caught by surprise turned around and slugged his teammate in the arm, not in a confrontational way, but in a way that said, “Dude, very $*&#@% funny, but cut it out, OK?”

He then proceeded to use a little extra soap as he finished his shower.

No one thought to report it as a “hazing incident,” and both players remained friends. At that time, and in that place, it seemed as if those involved agreed The Line had not been crossed.

You could argue otherwise. But the incident passed, with no repercussions.

How does that compare to what happened at Hart High School last week? Difficult to say.

It’s a different time. A different place. Different participants. Different dynamics. Different actions.

But, based on the consequences, it appears The Line was crossed.

Three Hart football players were suspended from school and kicked off the team, for their suspected roles in a “hazing” type of incident, just as the Indians prepared for their first-round playoff game against Glendora.

One of the players — the first one kicked off the team — was confirmed to be place-kicker Paul Weinstein. I know the disclosure of the player’s identity has caused no small number of headaches for the adults on the Hart campus.

But, in all fairness to anyone at Hart who may be taking heat for that, let the record reflect that, when our sports staff started calling about the incident, they already knew the player’s identity. Our staff’s conversations with Hart officials merely confirmed it.

The next day, two more players were released from the team for their suspected roles in the incident. Their identities have not been confirmed by school officials, but as the week wore on we developed pretty strong information on who they are.

If nothing else, it figured to become pretty obvious to anyone who went to Friday night’s game and compared the team’s roster to the squad that took the field.

Sometimes in the newspaper business, we don’t print everything we know. We have judgment calls to make. We have to decide how much detail to include, when to use names and when not to, and we have to decide whether certain pieces of information are corroborated well enough to use in print.

In this particular case, we had the name of a player who was kicked off one of the most prominent high school football teams in Southern California over his suspected role in an on-campus hazing incident. His identity was well-corroborated, and it was confirmed that he had been removed from the team.

This was a teen who played a key role in his team’s recent victory over a major local rival — someone who, despite the fact that his birth certificate says he’s still a minor, is for all intents and purposes a public figure in this town.

We published his name. We omitted some details of the incident.

The omissions were made — and continue to be made — because of several factors. For example, despite having what I would call “pretty good” information about the exact nature of the incident, it hasn’t been corroborated through any official sources and there is no public record or law enforcement report available to chronicle it.

Further, we have some concern that publishing the details may unnecessarily cause further embarrassment to the alleged victim of the incident.

This doesn’t rise to the level of, for example, a rape case or something like that, where most responsible media outlets refrain from publishing the name of an alleged victim. However, under the circumstances and considering the nature of the incident, publishing the boy’s name would seem gratuitous.

The incident, as we’ve been told, was not “violent,” per se. Weinstein’s attorney, in an interview with The Signal on Thursday, likened it to relatively harmless horseplay.

“I can assure the public nobody was physically harmed in the incident,” said Tony Zinnanti, a local attorney who, as it happens, has served as an on-again, off-again columnist for The Signal over the past several years.

“The nature of the incident was more in terms of shenanigans,” Zinnanti said. “We are not talking about a hazing incident where someone was physically harmed, like other hazing incidents we’ve all heard about.”

I consider Tony a friend and I respect him. He’s passionate about individuals’ rights and has a strong sense of right and wrong. However...

If what I’ve heard of the incident is true — and admittedly, that’s an “if” — I’d have to disagree with Tony and say that, while it’s true no physical harm was done, it went well beyond “shenanigans,” and crossed The Line.

I give credit to the administration at Hart for responding the way it has. Hart is a school that has become synonymous with football success for the past two decades, and here they were, on the opening week of the CIF playoffs, facing a situation that, from what we’ve heard, called for disciplinary action.

What did they do?

They suspended from school and released from the team three players, including one who recently booted a 45-yard field goal to beat Valencia High School and who is widely regarded as a valuable threat to pin opponents deep in their own zone on every Hart kick-off.

In other words, they didn’t sweep it under the rug to protect the team’s playoff chances. They upheld their roles as educators first. They took what they thought was the appropriate disciplinary action, with no artificial stalling to allow the boys to keep playing football.

I commend them for that.

You could argue — and Zinnanti will — that the boys, Weinstein in particular, were denied due process.

Perhaps. And, yes, we must always bear in mind the importance of the presumption of innocence until someone is proven guilty.

But, this is a case in which, it appears, there will be no criminal charges — so it’s up to the school to handle it.

Playing football is a privilege. I remember back in my high school days, we were warned in no uncertain terms that if we were, for example, caught with drugs, or engaging in any behavior that might be embarrassing to the team, we could be released at the coaches’ discretion. There was a code of conduct and we were expected to abide by it.

They didn’t say, “Well, if you get arrested, and charged with a crime, we’ll wait for you to be convicted before making our decision...”

Oh no. The punishment would be handed down well before that.

Most of us never got into a position where we did something — or, at least, got caught doing something — that would put us in danger of being kicked off the team. But, teenagers being the turbulent creatures that they are, sometimes they will exercise poor judgment and do things that, a decade from now, they’ll wish they hadn’t done.

Sometimes, The Line is crossed and hard lessons are learned. Boys will be boys. And when they do, the adults have to be the adults.

That’s what happened at Hart.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager. His column appears Sundays in the opinion section and Tuesdays on page A2.

← Back to 2005

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:8330.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,367 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [General Manager; for The Signal]
  • text:valley_names [5 distinct/5 mentions: Valencia, Saugus, Hart High, Saugus High, Valencia High]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0