ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

One Lump or Two? Punishment Should Fit Crime

“See what she can do, Tim!”

It was my high school football pal, Dave, piping up from the back seat as we crossed McBean Parkway onto Rockwell Canyon Road.

It was nighttime, circa 1982. Back then, Rockwell Canyon was kind of a lonely stretch of road — well-lit and just as wide as it is now, but after about 8 o’clock you pretty much could have that ribbon of asphalt to yourself.

I had just gotten my driver’s license a few weeks before. We were in my first car, a 1973 Oldsmobile Cutlass.

It had not been my father’s Oldsmobile. But, it HAD been my grandmother’s. It was an orange-ish rust color. It had white vinyl seats. And, it had a 350 V-8 that belied its grandmotherly appearance.

I opened ’er up.

That gas-guzzling V-8 pulled us smoothly away from the intersection, and I mashed my stupid, dopey, teenage-guy foot right to the floor.

Within a few seconds we got going pretty good. Let’s just say, quite a bit faster than the posted 45-mph speed limit.

Just as we passed College of the Canyons, we saw a local sheriff’s patrol car pulling out of the driveway.

He had me, dead to rights.

It was my first ticket. I had to go home and tell my mom. Then, I had to go to juvenile traffic court, where a judge sufficiently scared the bejeebers out of me.

There were consequences. It cost a few bucks. There was traffic school, and this was back when traffic school meant a full day watching “Red Asphalt” — not just reading a booklet and taking an e-mail quiz.

Was it the last stupid thing I ever did as a teenage driver? Well, no. But having to pay the consequences — and having to deal with The Law — I’m sure, made me safer than I would have been if I had gotten off, scot-free.

There’s a pretty big difference between what I did and what Paul Weinstein did a couple of weeks ago. But, I think there’s a parallel.

By now, the saga of the Hart High School football “hazing” incident is pretty familiar to most Signal readers.

The story has captured the community’s attention, and many residents have opinions about it that they wish to express in our newspaper. The undeniable fact is, this incident has shocked many local folks who were unaware of the sorts of things that apparently go on among high school football teammates.

Some of us have gotten more of an education than we bargained for, and the word “teabag” has taken on new, unwelcome meaning, as a verb.

Weinstein is the placekicker who was booted from the Hart football team just before the CIF playoffs began. His ouster was punishment for an on-campus “hazing” incident in which at least two teammates (who were also kicked off the team) held down a younger player while Weinstein dropped his drawers and “teabagged” the kid.

The teabagging — which involves the uninvited placement of one’s genitalia upon the head and/or face of another person — apparently was done in retribution for an earlier verbal conflict between the victim and some of his older teammates.

As the Hart high school district prepared to pursue the expulsion of Weinstein, his attorney, former Signal columnist Tony Zinnanti, prepared to go to war over the matter.

He said he’d not only fight the expulsion, but also seek to have Weinstein reinstated on the team. Zinnanti arranged for Weinstein to grant The Signal’s sports staff an interview, and in that interview the player admitted to his participation in the teabagging incident, chalking it up as a rite of passage that has been endured by various players — including himself.

Thing is, when the story of the interview was published, it didn’t evoke the kind of reaction Zinnanti apparently wanted. Rather than being sympathetic to Weinstein, readers were repulsed. And rather than taking up his cause, The Signal editorialized that what Weinstein did was a crime.

We stand by that assertion.

As you might imagine, Zinnanti is none too pleased by that. He believes his client’s name has been unnecessarily dragged through the mud, and he blames The Signal for it.

It’s certainly true that Weinstein has taken a lot of public fire for this incident. Thing is, the Weinstein camp sought the publicity. Zinnanti was going to wage all-out war on all comers, and he was going to do it in the newspaper.

It backfired.

Truth be told, I’m hoping this situation winds down, for the sake of all involved. I fully intend — barring new developments — for this to be the last I say about it. Here goes:

I believe the punishment should fit the crime. That means it should not be too light, but it should not be exceedingly harsh, either.

In this case, Weinstein and his accomplices already have been punished in one way by being kicked off the football team. That’s pretty significant.

Add to that the publicity that has now surrounded the case, and I’m sure the entire Weinstein family would say the stress and strain of dealing with the situation has been a significant punishment, too.

Now, there’s talk of expulsion — not just from Hart High School, but from the entire William S. Hart Union High School District.

The latter, I think, would be taking it a bit far. I think a case could be made for removing Weinstein — and maybe even his accomplices — from the Hart campus, but I don’t think an educational banishment from the entire Santa Clarita Valley is necessary.

So, on the expulsion front, I guess I’m a moderate. I don’t think the kid should be forced to finish his education in Sylmar. Let him stay close to home.

There’s still another front to be considered: Local law enforcement has taken a “hands off” approach to this case, supposedly because the victim and his family did not wish to pursue it.

The only reason it’s even in doubt is that the victim was a teammate of Weinstein’s. If he and his buddies went up to a random stranger and did the same thing, you can bet your Christmas money they’d land in the back of a squad car.

Take it a step further: Less than a year from now, these guys could be in the workplace. Guess what happens if you forcibly “teabag” a co-worker? Yep. You get fired, you get arrested, and you AND your employer get sued.

So, yes, this is a matter that is a legitimate issue for a criminal proceeding. But would I throw the book at the kid?

No.

You don’t give someone the death penalty for stealing a car stereo, and I wouldn’t say a first offender who “teabags” a football teammate should end up in juvenile hall with the dope dealers and the underage murderers.

By the accounts I’ve heard, Weinstein is an otherwise good kid who made a mistake. He should be treated accordingly.

Yet, we still have to remember our obligation to teach kids that “mistakes” such as sexual battery come with consequences of their own, other than being kicked off a football team or enduring some negative publicity.

If the boy were to be found guilty, or make a plea agreement, perhaps some community service would be in order — maybe something benefiting domestic violence victims, or helping the underprivileged.

So, no, they shouldn’t lock him up and throw away the key. And no, he doesn’t belong in a state facility with hardened inner-city gangsters. And no, they shouldn’t deny him the opportunity to finish his high school education here in the SCV.

But he should have to face The Law. Just chalking this one up as “one of those things kids do” is unacceptable.

A message must be sent that this sort of behavior is beyond the pale, that the perpetrator is NOT the victim, that one must take responsibility for one’s actions, and that there will be tangible consequences beyond just missing a few high school football games.

If there’s any doubt that this should be a criminal matter, I ask what’s worse: Going 25 mph over the speed limit, or having two big, strong buddies hold someone down so you can smack your genitals on his head against his will?

Speeding can land you in court.

Teabagging should, too.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager.

← Back to 2005

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:8416.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,405 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [General Manager; Signal editor; Signal editorial]
  • text:valley_names [7 distinct/8 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, College of the Canyons, Hart High, William S. Hart, Hart Union]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0