A federal judge has denied Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital’s contempt request, ending its attempt to resolve its injured employees’ unpaid claims through the U.S. Bankruptcy Court instead of through the state’s jurisdictional board.
Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Greenwald ruled last week to not place sanctions against the Department of Industrial Relations for ordering Newhall Memorial to turn over its remaining self-insured claim files for payment by its security fund.
Dean Fryer, spokesman for the California Department of Industrial Relations, which challenged Newhall Memorial’s request in August, said Tuesday the judge’s ruling verifies that the jurisdiction for payment of self-insured workers’ compensation claims is the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board and the Self Insurers’ Security Fund.
“The judge sided with us in agreeing that the claims should be taken over by the security fund and that it is the proper place to dispense the payments,” Fryer said. “This basically verifies what we have known all along, that the purpose of the fund is to pay workers’ compensation liabilities if the employer is unable to pay the benefits,” he said. “This just solidifies that even more so.”
Newhall Memorial, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection Nov. 26, had argued that its injured employees’ unpaid claims fell under the jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court because they were pre-bankruptcy claims.
Newhall Memorial President Roger Seaver said the judge’s ruling is beneficial because it clarifies how the hospital will settle its injured employees’ unpaid claims.
Department of Industrial Relations’ dispute with Newhall Memorial began when it contacted the hospital in March, after learning of the bankruptcy filing, to ascertain how the hospital intended to handle the claims.
Since Newhall Memorial hadn’t filed a bankruptcy petition to seek the court’s permission to continue paying benefits, the department automatically conducted an audit to determine the hospital’s remaining liabilities.
The hospital was placed in default after it ceased to pay its claim benefits in May, triggering the Department of Industrial Relations to order the hospital’s $500,000 security deposit and all liability for the claims to be turned over to the Self Insurers’ Security Fund.
Newhall Memorial then filed a motion to seek sanctions against the Department of Industrial Relations for ordering the hospital’s remaining self-insured claim files to be turned over for payment by the security fund, along with the hospital’s security deposit posted by the hospital.
