The ability to sue government agencies when they hurt the “little guy,” whether through negligence or willful misconduct, is a fundamental American right.
But as with most rights, there are small groups of people who bend the law and abuse this right for their own personal enrichment. Last year, Congress clamped down on shady lawyers who file frivolous class-action lawsuits that the lawyers know will never go to trial because it’s cheaper for a company to settle out of court, often for millions of dollars.
We desperately need similar action from the California Legislature to stop what has happened time and again in the Santa Clarita Valley in the past several years.
There is a small group of people in this town — and we literally mean about a handful — who have figured out how to abuse the judicial system and put money into their lawyers’ pockets at the expense of Santa Clarita Valley taxpayers.
You might remember that last year, in the most brazen example of conflict-of-interest we can remember, Lynne Plambeck, a member of the Newhall County Water Board, filed papers asking a court to award $285,000 to the attorneys for special-interest groups that were suing her own water agency and other local water utilities.
Ultimately the court cut her request in half and awarded $135,906 to one of the special-interest groups that sued over a technical error in an obscure report that ultimately had no impact on the people of the Santa Clarita Valley. (As the water agencies correctly predicted, we got all the water we needed.)
Just who paid that $135,906? You did. It was your money. You paid it through the taxes and/or water fees you paid to the Castaic Lake Water Agency, Newhall County or Valencia Water Co.
Asking to take your money and award it to a special-interest group was a mind-boggling thing for Plambeck to do. We called for her resignation from the Newhall County Water Board. She’s still there, but fortunately for the valley’s water users — you — she no longer has any sway with the agency.
But the sad thing is that it worked — even if the court did cut the award in half.
That same special-interest group — Friends of the Santa Clara River, headed by a guy from Newbury Park, of all places, who would have you believe they care about the environment as long as their attorneys get paid — has done it again.
Last week these so-called “Friends” filed a lawsuit challenging the water agencies’ 2005 Urban Water Management Plan — an official document the agencies are required to draft to show how much water they’ll be getting out of the ground and from the State Water Project for the next five years.
It’s what worked last time. Remember, it was the 2000-2005 water plan that ultimately put your money into their attorneys’ pockets. That time, they attacked the water agencies for failing to include information about groundwater contamination in the 2000 report that wasn’t even known until 2001. Were they technically correct? The court thought so. But what was the upshot? Nothing, as far as your water supply was concerned. More than $100,000, as far as your pocketbook was concerned.
Get a load of their allegations this time.
The guy from Newbury Park says the supply of state water we get from the Sierra Nevadas “is likely to diminish due to global warming. Therefore, the water supply available to California will be less by that.”
That’s right. Global warming is going to evaporate the Sierra Nevada snowpack. In the next four years.
Heck, maybe an asteroid will hit Planet Earth, destroying the California Aqueduct (supposedly one of only two man-made objects that can be seen from space, the other being the Great Wall of China).
Or maybe terrorists will dump arsenic in Castaic Lake.
Frankly, we’re a little more concerned about that last one than we are with asteroids hitting Earth or the world drying up through global warming by 2010.
What you’ve got to understand about the Urban Water Management Plan is that the local water agencies use the BEST scientific data available to gauge how much water we’ll get out of the ground and from the State Water Project in the next five years. Not voodoo. Not Osama’s videotapes. Scientific data.
And truth be told, the scientists know all about global warming.
The State Water Project has been with us since the early 1960s. In four decades of experience, the water experts are able to predict with tremendous accuracy how much water we’ll get.
The problem isn’t just the $135,906 that Plambeck helped put into the pockets of the attorneys for her “Friends.” That $135,906 doesn’t count the hundreds of thousands of additional dollars of your money that the water agencies had to spend to defend against this frivolous lawsuit.
In fact, in recent years, the water agencies say they’ve had to spend $1.4 million of your money to fend off these frivolous lawsuits that these special-interest groups seem to be filing with greater and greater frequency.
We need the Legislature to take action now. You deserve to have your $1.4 million back, and we need laws to prevent these frivolous, self-enriching lawsuits from ever being filed again.
