More information is needed before the City Council can decide if a major trash sorting facility should be installed inside the city.
A debate surfaced during a special meeting Tuesday, leaving council members to request further studies before determining whether a material recoveries facility, or MRF — a plant that separates recyclable goods from other trash — is needed in Santa Clarita.
The council is currently drafting new trash franchise agreements after voting in March to open the $135 million contracts to a competitive bidding process.
The council was polarized about the need, or lack thereof, for an MRF. The meeting ended with the council asking for a feasibility study from the consultant hired to guide the city through the franchise drafting process.
“I don’t want to trust anybody when it comes to our trash,” Mayor Frank Ferry said. “We need to be 100 percent responsible.”
Ferry said the city should have full control over trash after it was discovered last year that the city fell behind in meeting the state-mandated recycling rate of 50 percent. Faulty reporting by a local hauler was the primary cause, a city-commissioned study said.
Laith Ezzet, a consultant with Hilton Farnkopf & Hobson, the firm hired to help the city write the new contracts, suggested the city separate trash collection and the MRF process because the company that gets the contract to haul trash may not be the same company that owns the landfill in which the waste will be deposited.
Ezzet said he will do a thorough review, measuring the pros and cons for the city to have an MRF, and report back to the council Oct. 24.
Councilman Cameron Smyth said the council was right in requesting more information.
“I think the jury is still out if an MRF is needed within the city or not,” Smyth said.
There are two types of MRFs: “dirty MRFs,” where recyclables are separated from other trash; and “clean MRFs,” where commingled recyclables are sorted only. The study will review both types of facilities.
Operators of the two local landfills said the city doesn’t need an MRF.
“The need for an MRF inside the city of Santa Clarita is a lesser necessity than implementing new programs and enhancing participation in recycling,” said Matt Terrell, general manager of Atlas Transport, one of the local haulers.
Atlas’ parent company, Republic Consolidated, owns Chiquita Canyon Landfill, which is currently constructing a facility.
Terrell said installing an MRF inside city limits won’t increase recycling. Stronger education and more programs do that, he said.
Greg Loughnane, district manager for Browning Ferris Industries, agreed.
“The city has a great opportunity to take advantage of two nearby landfills,” Loughnane said. “We agree with the consultant that building an MRF should be separated from the collection process.”
BFI owns the Sunshine Canyon Landfill off of San Fernando Road in Granada Hills. It has an MRF there as well.
“(The) burden of meeting the (state required) recycling goal will be on the haulers, not the city,” he said.
Loughnane said BFI will apply to become a hauler for the city.
Ferry said he will wait for the study before making a decision.
“We need to be accountable,” he said.
The council voted 3-2 in March to put the lucrative commercial and residential trash contracts out to bid, forcing current haulers Republic and Waste Management Inc. to reapply for the job.
A draft contract is expected to be ready by November.
