It was supposed to be a “Beautiful Entry,” complete with homes, parks and open space, with a 360-degree view of the Santa Clarita Valley. Some call it “the doughnut hole,” while others call it a “toxic football.”
Rest assured, one thing it won’t be called anymore is Porta Bella. That’s what city officials are saying, anyway.
It’s back to its old name, Whittaker-Bermite, the 1,000-acre home of the defunct munitions plant where fireworks, dynamite, bombs, missiles and other weaponry were manufactured for the federal government for decades. Whittaker Corp. called it quits in the late 1980s and proposed to urbanize the site by building nearly 3,000 homes, a commercial center, industrial park, elementary school and fire station on the prime real estate land.
Located west of San Fernando Road and south of Soledad Canyon Road, the property is key to the city’s transportation plans, including road connections between Via Princessa in Canyon Country to Wiley Canyon Road in Newhall. Also planned is the Santa Clarita Parkway, which would run across the property and connect with Magic Mountain Parkway.
However, lingering below the surface are some 40 different contaminants in the soil and groundwater, including ammonium perchlorate. There are also landfills, filled with unexploded shells and other hazardous materials, some of which have been unearthed in the past few weeks.
The hold up has been financing the studies to locate the source of the contamination, then how to clean it. A state regulatory agency has been involved since the mid-1990s, but its hands have been tied as of late because the current landowner can’t finance any more studies.
The city’s recently renewed vigor over the acreage in the heart of town was boosted last week when a North Carolina-based firm expressed interest in purchasing the land. City officials were already on a path to get the company responsible for polluting the land to pick up the multi-million-dollar cleanup tab, but has run into some stumbling blocks.
The next question for the city became, “Where do we go from here?”
The 14-point plan
Serious about taking action, the City Council formed a subcommittee at the beginning of the year to craft an action plan to get the city back on track with the project.
The current landowner, Santa Clarita LLC, a subsidiary of Phoenix-based Remediation Financial Inc., had been claiming for months it didn’t have the finances to clean the property. It had made repeated requests with the city to overturn a clause in the Porta Bella development agreement that forbids any construction on the site until the soil and groundwater have been purged of contaminants to the state’s specifications. RFI said if it could begin to build in phases on the land as it is cleaned bit by bit, the company could generate the capital needed to continue with the cleanup efforts.
The council didn’t budge from a prior council decision to require full cleanup before any homes could be built, and RFI put the land on the market.
Mayor Frank Ferry, a one-time proponent of so-called “phased” cleanup and construction, said bargaining with RFI was pointless and cost the city time and money. Ferry and Councilman Bob Kellar make up the council’s Bermite subcommittee.
“The greatest thing the committee has discovered is that there is no one right answer (about the cleanup),” Ferry said. “We’re not going to be short-sighted this time. We’re not going to close any doors or just go down one tunnel.”
The answer? A 14-point strategy drafted by the subcommittee, city planners and consultants who specialize in brownfields (properties that have high levels of pollution) to get the city on what it feels is the right track.
The plan’s action items include: develop a more comprehensive citywide public outreach program; monitor the Army Corps of Engineers’ water monitoring tests and unexploded waste cleanup; continue with the multi-jurisidictional stakeholder meetings; pursue historic insurance opportunities for cleanup funding; conduct thorough research on potential buyer, the North Carolina company Cherokee Investment Partners, or any potential buyer; and conduct research on other successful perchlorate cleanup projects.
City officials know this is a gregarious plan that will require a lot of cooperation from all impacted parties … something it wasn’t getting a year ago.
“We want to get the message to Whittaker pretty clearly that we are paying attention to them,” City Planning Director Jeff Lambert said.
Lambert said the city has been at the negotiating table trying to get Whittaker to commit funds to the cleanup efforts through its old insurance policies. The city has also requested information from an ongoing federal court case between the former owner and the Castaic Lake Water Agency which has been sealed.
He said the city, so far, has been nice about its requests.
“We are fully prepared not to be nice,” Lambert said.
And, more importantly, he said everyone is on board with the city’s plan.
A group of local legislators and water and school board members have met frequently to help generate information and ideas, which helped lead to the creation of the plan.
In the past, a divided council, as well as some to zero communication between the city, water agencies, school districts and other land owners, caused friction about the then-Porta Bella project, which became a taboo.
Now, Ferry said the city and all stakeholders are in sync and have the opportunity to approach the site by bringing everyone’s ideas and concerns to the table. The result is the 14-point plan.
Ferry said the city was at a disadvantage in 1995 when Porta Bella was approved by the City Council because much of the environmental damage wasn’t known until 1997, when perchlorate was discovered in water wells.
This time, he said, the city will cover every angle to make sure all of its bases are covered.
“You learn from your mistakes,” he said. “Some of the pitfalls that may have been made five years ago won’t be made again.”
1,000-acre history
The history of the property is almost as explosive as the products made there for 50 years.
Like much of the Santa Clarita Valley at the time, The Newhall Land and Farming Co. owned pieces of Bermite from 1924 to 1934, but never set up shop there.
The Los Angeles Powder Co. purchased the property and began to manufacture dynamite from 1934 to 1936, while on another section of the property the Halifax Explosives Co. made fireworks until 1942.
E.P. Halliburton Inc. made oil field explosives there for a short time in 1942. Then, the Bermite Powder Co. moved in and began making flares, bombs and explosives, during World War II and the Korean War.
The Whittaker Corp. took over in 1967 to make gas generators, rockets, practice bombs and Sidewinder missiles. The company ceased operations around 1987.
The California Department of Toxic Substances Control forced Whittaker to sign a consent order — a legally-binding agreement where the company vows to clean the site to state specifications — in November 1994. At the time, Whittaker was trying to push through Porta Bella.
The state and federal government seized files from Whittaker’s offices to find out what kinds of materials were still left on the land. Those files are currently being used by the Army Corps of Engineers, DTSC, CLWA and the current landowners to characterize the extent and type of contamination both on and off the property. It was then confirmed that perchlorate was used by Whittaker.
In 1995, the City Council OK’d the Porta Bella Specific Plan, which was a blueprint for the planned community. The city and Whittaker penned a contract in 1996 that allowed Porta Bella to be constructed only after the entire site was cleaned. The “no phase development” clause would later become the city’s trump card.
Tests on the site in 1997 with new technologies detected perchlorate in the soil beneath the property and in four wells west of the site. Those wells, belonging to the Santa Clarita Water Co., Valencia Water Co. and Newhall County Water District, were subsequently shut down.
Perchlorate was used by Whittaker in rockets, and causes hypothyroidism when ingested by humans. The federal Environmental Protection Agency is currently researching the toxin’s effects and is expected to lower the allowable amount in drinking water to somewhere around 4 parts per million.
Fast forward to January 1999 when the Phoenix-based Remediation Financial Inc. purchased the land from Whittaker for $15 million. RFI set up a subsidiary, Santa Clarita LLC, to be the local arm in charge of its cleanup efforts.
In March of the same year, the city signed a non-binding agreement to let RFI develop the property in phases, in exchange for an easement for Golden Valley Road, an extended lease for the Soledad Canyon Metrolink station and roughly five acres for a future city municipal site.
There was a renewed energy at the time of the RFI purchase, officials said, because a company was willing to get rid of the contamination, and more importantly, the perchlorate.
Then, no one could pin-point where the energy diffused and the conflict began.
The city became disenchanted with RFI’s lack of organization in submitting site workplans on time, while RFI didn’t like that it gave the city what it asked for in the 1999 agreement (the road easement, the station lease) and it wasn’t getting the phased development clause amended in return.
CLWA and the three local water purveyors sued RFI and Whittaker in November 2000, citing the lack of action by the current landowner to clean the water, which was costing the agency millions. The lawsuit, which is still active in a federal court, seeks $35 million in damages due to the closed wells.
RFI counter-sued in February 2001, claiming the agency’s drawing water from the wells spread the perchlorate contamination.
All the information in the cases is sealed on a request from the plaintiffs and defendants, something the city is trying to change.
Also in February, RFI signed an “enforceable agreement” with DTSC that states the company will make sure the land is cleaned to state standards, but never mentions how it will clean it, or who will pay for it.
Several lawsuits then poured in filed by contractors used by RFI that claim the company failed to pay for work done on the site. Then, in July 2001, RFI sued the city, claiming the city has failed to follow through on the 1999 agreement. The city, at the time, was beginning to put the finishing touches on Golden Valley Road, which reaches through the northeastern portion of the site. RFI closed the road, which forced the city to pursue eminent domain proceedings.
By then, RFI was also threatening to close the Soledad Metrolink station, which also sent the city flying into court to stop the move. A superior court judge agreed, and the station remained open.
Friction was at an all-time high by the end of 2001, when DTSC began to demand RFI begin cooperating with the February agreement. DTSC officials said the company failed to submit workplans by the date demanded in the agreement.
That’s when RFI said it didn’t have the money to further fund the cleanup with the phased development clause being lifted.
City planners began looking to see if RFI was in compliance with the 1996 contract it signed with Whittaker, which RFI assumed when it bought the land. This past spring, the Santa Clarita Planning Commission found the landowner out of compliance with the agreement and the same decision is scheduled to go before the City Council on Oct. 22.
However, Lambert said the next two months are the most important to the city, and it shouldn’t hastily nix the agreement because it could provide leverage for the city in its impending battle to get insurance money from Whittaker.
Whittaker is currently redrafting the November 1994 consent order it signed with the DTSC.
According to Sara Amir, DTSC Southern California branch chief, an update was needed because of all the new information that has been discovered in the eight years since the agreement was penned. Amir said the agency expects to have the new version signed by the end of the month.
Lambert said by the city keeping the development agreement and Porta Bella Specific Plan intact, it will be able to use it as leverage against Whittaker to force the company to clean the property to residential standards, the highest cleanup level demanded by the state. The city doesn’t want to take the chance that Whittaker will clean the property to industrial standards, one of the lowest allowed by the state.
He also said that if the city voids the agreement, it could shoo away potential buyers, including the latest nibble by Cherokee Investment Partners.
Fresh blood?
The Raleigh, N.C.-based Cherokee Investment Partners let its interest in the Whittaker-Bermite property be known last week, which invigorated the newly pumped and primed city.
Dwight Stenseth, managing director of Cherokee’s Denver office, said the company is in initial phases of its education about the land.
“We don’t have a whole lot of knowledge about the property,” Stenseth said. “We would have to do our due diligence.”
Stenseth said the company was approached about the property a few months ago, but isn’t ready to make a decision.
“From a hard economic perspective, we don’t have all the information we need to make a decision,” he said.
The company is aware of some of the history between the city and RFI.
“It’s unfortunate the path this project has taken lately,” Stenseth said. “I don’t know if our involvement will help those things or not.”
The city knew RFI was looking to unload the land, but was surprised it got a bite.
“To be honest, we thought that would never happen,” Lambert said about Cherokee’s interest.
The city hasn’t met with Cherokee yet, but Lambert said it will focus on finding out about Cherokee’s intentions and hopes the city, if Cherokee buys, will have a healthy working relationship with the company.
Lambert also said the city would be upfront about finding out about Cherokee’s investors and financing mechanisms, something it never got from RFI.
“We need to make sure they have the money,” he said.
Stenseth said he understands the city’s concerns about financing and phased development.
“In most cases, we clean up the project before we try to market and sell it,” he said about Cherokee’s cleanup style. “But it all depends on the economics.”
Stenseth said Cherokee has a strong interest in getting something done with RFI.
Lambert is glad and said the city wants to give Cherokee a chance to prove itself.
Next move
The City Council will be asked Tuesday to approve $200,000 to continue its drive. Specialized brownfields attorneys were hired to work with the city in the hope of checking off some of the points of the plan.
In the meantime, Lambert said the city will continue the momentum over the next few weeks.
“We know what to ask now,” he said. “We just need to let it play out.”
That was good news to Ferry’s ears.
“The council is on the same page,” he said. “Each of us in the past only had one lens and only saw something from our point of view. Now, we are hoping we can share perspectives.”
