ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

A stinkrose by any name still smells

A rose by any other name smells as sweet... EXCEPT if that flower is really a stinkrose by the name of Porta Bella. Calling it “Porta Bella,” “Port-a-potty,” “Port o’Death” or ‘Whittaker-Bermite” does not change the fact the 1,000-acre site of the former munitions plant has the potential to be another “Love Canal.”

For those not familiar with the term, “Love Canal,” I’ll elaborate.

Love Canal, in upstate New York, burst upon the public scene in 1978 after it was discovered that homes and a school built upon a former chemical landfill were filled with leaching toxic substances in the soil and air.

By 1980, the federal government had identified 248 chemicals at the Love Canal dump site and the current total now exceeds 400.

Health problems plagued the residents of the Love Canal neighborhood — mysterious illnesses, high rates of miscarriages, birth defects, chromosome damage and diseases of the liver and kidneys, the two organs of the body where chemicals are concentrated to detoxify. A health study was conducted by volunteer scientists and community members revealing 56 percent of children born between 1974 and 1978 suffered birth defects. The miscarriage rate increased 300 percent among women who moved to Love Canal. Urinary-tract disease also increased 300 percent, with a great number of children being affected.

An ongoing health study conducted by The New York State Department of Health to look at cancer rates of people who lived near Love Canal between 1940 and 1978 has not demonstrated an increased risk of cancer for Love Canal residents, but does not rule out Love Canal for the cancers that have occurred.

Certainly the Whittaker-Bermite site would most likely not ooze chemicals into people’s yards, gardens and homes... but what about the contaminants you can’t see or smell?

What about the toxic dust blowing from the site during the grading and digging during clean-up efforts?

The ability to identify and remediate toxic sites has improved tremendously since the ’50s and ’60s. But has the ability to clean those sites improved to the point where you would want to raise your family atop such an area? There are those who believe a site like Whittaker-Bermite can be cleaned. I don’t buy it.

Look at what the scientists of yesterday brought us...

Today we look at the routine practice of exposing children to high-dose x-rays, as they did 40 years ago, with horror.

We are appalled science can create pharmaceuticals, in all innocence, that turn deadly as in the case of Thalidomide and Fen-Phen. (Thalidomide caused birth defects and Fen-Phen can cause fatal pulmonary hypertension).

Our technology isn’t so advanced we can cure cancer or keep people from dying from tiny germs that invade our blood system.

Just this summer mosquitos have carried a new deadly threat across our country, West Nile Virus, and we’ve been helpless to stop it.

The decision makers of their day thought it was just jim-dandy to build homes and a school atop the toxic miasma of Love Canal.

So... would you would believe someone who told you they could cleanse dozens of toxic contaminants mixed into hundreds of thousands of tons of soil on a 1,000-acre site?

Would you believe they could clean the toxic land so perfectly that they could build 3,000 homes in addition to businesses and schools on the site?

Would you live there?

What will we find 10, 20, 50 or 100 years from now that will make such assurances seem to be the folly of arrogant men?

A thousand years from now, will people laugh at our futile attempts to clean what can’t be cleaned, much as we look askance at ancient medical practices?

Do we really believe technology has reached its zenith when we can’t even prevent a tiny mosquito from carrying death across the nation?

I know I don’t believe it. Cancer has exploded across the nation. Childhood cancers continue to increase. Many think the increasing cancer rates can be tied to environmental toxins and pollutants.

Porta Bella, or Whittaker-Bermite, is not an answer to transportation problems in the SCV, a housing or school crunch or anything else.

It is a beast of mythological proportions, like an ogre or troll hiding under a bridge, waiting to snatch the unwary and devour them.

I do not believe the technology exists to adequately clean a site like Whittaker-Bermite. I believe the cure may even be worse than the disease as toxic clouds of dust waft across the SCV during grading, digging and disposal.

While each generation believes its own technology to be unsurpassable, each generation that follows proves the technology of its fathers to be little better than an ancient shaman with beads and feathers.

Madame Curie didn’t understand the dangers of the radium she discovered and she died of its toxic causes.

Agent Orange was unleashed on the enemy in Vietnam, but our own soldiers fell victim to its toxic fallout.

Above-ground nuclear tests in the Nevada desert may have claimed hundreds of innocent victims (from cancer due to radiation) because no one realized the extreme danger. John Wayne may have even been a victim. His deadly cancer may have resulted from radiation exposure after shooting a movie in Nevada near one of the nuclear test sites.

There is a difference between radiation and toxic chemicals, but the dangers of both were little understood for many years.

The Santa Clarita Valley has hundreds of honest and hard-working small businessmen and women. The world is not like Santa Clarita. Out in its harsh climes honesty is as rare as a politician without a hand in your pocket. Would you buy a used car from Enron, Worldcom, Global Crossing, Arthur Anderson or Martha Stewart?

Remember the movie, “Erin Brockovich”? That wasn’t created from the mind of a Hollywood writer. That was real life and death. Company officials from Pacific Gas and Electric knew there was deadly hexavalent chromium (chromium 6) in the groundwater and still told residents it was safe to drink. Corporate greed knows no bounds.

Think before you buy any equally smelling sack of toxic garbage from anyone who wants to develop the Whittaker-Bermite site. They are merely trying to enrich themselves at the expense of unsuspecting families and children who might stumble into their toxic pit.

If you have to do something with the site, other than just leave it as is, pass a bond, clean it up as much as today’s technology can and build a park on the whole awful mess. Post big signs warning people what was there.

I realize that’s not a “sexy” solution because no one can line their pockets with crisp green bills.

I hope the decision-makers on Whittaker-Bermite think hard. I hope they think about how they would feel years down the road if a cancer cluster developed among a group of innocent children living within the confines of the Whittaker-Bermite site. Could you sleep at night knowing you might have contributed to such a horror? This isn’t about the rights of property owners, this is about protecting the public health... and the people of Santa Clarita are watching.

Michele E. Buttelman is the features editor of The Signal. She can be reached at [email protected].

← Back to 2002

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:957.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,202 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [[address]; features editor]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/5 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0