ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Fighting to Get Past Hart’s Spin Doctors

“No fight did take place. There has been no violence whatsoever on the campus.”

— Mike von Buelow

Assistant Superintendent, Personnel

Wm. S. Hart Union High School District

Radio interview with KHTS

April 28, 2:22 p.m.

It was about two hours after the fight started. Mike von Buelow says he honestly did not know, at the time, that violence had occurred on the campus of Hart High School.

It had.

Regardless of what you might have heard in the radio interview, there was a physical altercation. You just weren’t getting the truth about it. Whether you believe the misinformation was intentional or not, well, that’s up to you. More on that later.

By the time the radio interview occurred, police were just about done mopping up after the racially charged brawl that started at lunchtime. Several students had been taken into custody.

Credible sources put the number involved in the fighting at anywhere from 15 to 50. Hundreds more were involved in the “disturbance” without actually throwing punches.

Based on the information at the scene — even with the school’s all-too-typical clampdown on the press — it was ludicrous for anyone to assert “no violence whatsoever” had occurred.

Anything to put a happy face on the situation, I guess. That is what they do. Ask a student at Hart High whether the story will appear in the school paper, and the answer you’ll most likely hear — privately — is, “Just the sugarcoated version that won’t offend the administration.”

They know the difference. There are a lot of bright kids at Hart.

That’s just the start. What follows here are a few more illustrations of why government in general — and the Hart district in particular — needs to be kept under the watchful eyes of the public and the press.

These are reasons why we shouldn’t just take the district’s word for it when they illegally keep the press from covering news on a campus, then effectively pat citizens on the head and say, “Don’t worry, be happy.”

Among the notable examples in the aftermath of the April 28 altercation:

n School officials being muzzled by their superiors. (One Hart teacher, involved in a post-brawl forum with students, told this newspaper she could not comment until she received “permission” from Principal Gary Fuller. Permission was not granted.)

n The assistant superintendent dangling the prospect of allowing the press its lawful campus access for news coverage on the condition that the coverage be what he considers “fair.” This happened a week after the Hart incident, when it was rumored another altercation was brewing.

(Funny thing. We always strive for fairness in our news reporting; we consider that our responsibility. But, nowhere in the First Amendment is it stipulated that the government can restrict a free press if the government doesn’t think the coverage will be “fair.”)

n The school district’s PR flack telling the press, in advance, that if another news event were to occur on campus, journalists would again be locked out. (That’s in open defiance of state law.)

Then there’s the Hart district’s official “news” publication. In the quarterly “News & Views,” which is printed by The Signal and is inserted into today’s edition of the newspaper, the lead story is, “Hart District Graduates Hit Record Despite Exit Exam Requirements.”

OK, that’s good news — and pretty darn significant. But here’s the headline on their No. 2 story:

“Summer School Will Offer Remedial Enrichment Classes on Five Campuses.”

Then, further down on the front page is a story about the district’s “Diversity Action Plan.” It makes no mention of the two racially charged melees that occurred on Hart district campuses in the past quarter (the one at Hart and an earlier near-riot at Golden Valley High).

One has to turn to page 2 to find the first mention of the altercations, as Superintendent Jaime Castellanos comments on the Diversity Action Plan: “Incidents in the past month have shown that we still have work to do in this area.”

I guess they didn’t want to burden us with the details.

Also inside “News & Views,” you’ll find the story, “Student Forums Look at Solutions to Campus Issues.” There’s no mention of the on-campus violence other than to say student discussions have been held to “reduce tensions at schools.”

Wow. Slow down, guys. Such frank, open discussion of issues ... I’m not sure if we can take it.

I know, I know. News & Views is a PR organ, and I wouldn’t in a million years expect unblinking, probing news coverage in it — but come on. That’s all they could muster?

This, at a time when the question burning on the minds of most parents is, “What exactly is going on at our campuses and what is being done to keep my kid safe?”

What’s ironic is, the Hart district and local law enforcement have actually done a pretty good job of keeping your kids safe. I honestly believe that, in the week after the April 28 incident, the information gathering and preventive enforcement undertaken by the district and the Sheriff’s Department stopped at least two additional incidents from occurring on the Hart campus.

On that particular issue, I think the Sheriff’s Department, Hart High and the district deserve high marks. Thanks to those efforts, the situation at least seems to have calmed down.

But in their zeal to put on a happy face, control the spin and slap a pair of rose-colored glasses onto the face of every parent in the valley, the Hart district and its “official publication” ignored the elephant in the room.

Back to Mr. Von Buelow’s comments, made in an interview with Jason Endicott of KHTS-AM, the local radio station:

When Endicott launched the interview, it was 2:22 p.m. The brawl at Hart had occurred at lunchtime, and by the time the Von Buelow interview began, the crowd of students had been dispersed from the quad, a few arrests had been made and law enforcement and school officials had begun the orderly dismissal of the rest of the students.

The incident, basically, was over.

Everyone standing outside the gate of Hart High was aware violence had occurred on campus. The people flying the half-dozen or so helicopters that circled overhead were aware violence had occurred on campus. The several dozen sheriff’s deputies who had been called to the scene were aware there had been violence on campus.

And the teenagers who spoke to the press, both print and electronic, were well aware of it, even if some of them engaged in a little hyperbole or were misinformed on the details.

Regardless, just about anyone with a passing familiarity with it knew SOMETHING beyond a “discussion” or a “rumor” had occurred at Hart High.

Yet, Von Buelow went on the air, and this is what he said:

“Here’s what I know. We’re still gathering information but I think what I have is fairly accurate at this point. There was a report, rumors, circulating, among students that there was going to be a physical altercation between some students, the number I don’t know at this point, but it looks like it was a small number, probably two kids.

“And so there were a lot of kids milling about to see what was going on with the activity, and the administration and our sheriff’s deputy who works with us, the school resource officer, caught wind of it. They went out to make sure nothing took place. No fight did take place.

“There has been no violence whatsoever on the campus, and as the administrators and the deputies were trying to get the kids to get back to class now, and let’s get on with business as usual, the vast majority of the kids said ‘fine’ and nothing occurred, and went back to class.

“There was a group of students, however, who were resistant to that and were not following the directives of school personnel. And, as a result of that, there was some verbal exchange between them. They became disrespectful, and several kids, I don’t have the number yet, but several of the kids were taken into custody. And, they’ll have to deal with the Sheriff’s Department on that. The parents will undoubtedly be called to pick them up at the station.

“Since then, the school, in order to make sure that nothing did occur further, went into a safe mode, and so kids were in their classes, and told that we would dismiss them at the regular time at the end of the day. They’re doing that now, we’re in the process of that, and the kids are being safely escorted off by teachers and administrators, and there’s a number of deputies from the Sheriff’s Department there just to ensure that everything goes smoothly.”

Endicott seemed puzzled by Von Buelow’s comments, because he had heard conflicting information from people who had called the radio station.

The radio host asked: “You’re saying that there was no... no actual physical altercation took place today at all, it was basically a lot of talk running up to what could have possibly been that, and by the time that the school administrators got involved, it had already been more or less defused, is that safe to say?”

“That’s correct,” Von Buelow said.

Said Endicott: “OK, because we had reports from, I guess a couple of students, there might have been some people with the faculty injured, so those are all just rumors at this point, nobody actually is injured, and everybody’s OK?”

Said Von Buelow: “That’s correct. There was no physical altercation.”

But, there was.

One of two things happened, either of which is bothersome:

1) The assistant superintendent of the Hart school district lied to the public about it.

2) The assistant superintendent of the Hart school district didn’t know what everyone else seemed to know, some two hours after the incident started, and went on the air with bad information.

I spoke to Mr. Von Buelow last week. He said he simply had not received confirmation that a physical altercation had occurred.

“At that particular moment I had no report of any violence,” he told me. “I had talked to four or five people who were there, and I repeatedly asked the question, ‘Was there any physical violence that they were aware of?’”

In talking to Von Buelow, he seems quite sincere about it. “I honestly believed at that point that there was none,” he said.

I’m inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt, but I don’t think it looks all that much better if the district hadn’t nailed down that very important fact two hours after the violence occurred.

If Von Buelow was fed bad information, the question is, “Why?”

If he didn’t know, why didn’t he?

Everyone else seemed to know.

As it happened, the superintendent of the district, Jaime Castellanos, was out of town. But, in a later interview — after the basic truth of the brawl had been broadly reported in the media — Castellanos acknowledged that, yes, there had been a fight, and in fact there had been some injuries.

So now we at least have some truth, but we’re still lacking details, and we still have a school district that seems more concerned with controlling the spin — and downplaying the real problems — than it is with the public’s right to know.

Here’s what all of this tells us:

Regardless of its intent, the Hart district can’t be relied upon in a crisis to provide accurate, truthful, complete information. What you’ll get is spin control, with pertinent facts omitted — such as, for example, the existence of a major, racially charged brawl. Such omissions may be intentional or unintentional, but either way, you’re not getting the straight scoop.

All of it shows why we should not trust any government agency to be the sole source of information on matters of public interest, especially in a crisis. This is why someone other than a government official needs to be your eyes and ears, to tell you, “Here’s what happened, and here’s how they handled it...”

It’s why we need a free, unobstructed press.

Even if it makes the government uncomfortable.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager.

← Back to 2006

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:9688.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,047 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [7 distinct/17 mentions: Hart High, Hart district, Golden Valley High, Hart Union]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Tim Whyte]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0