How many players in the Foothill League were indispensable?
How many players made a huge difference on defense and offense?
And how many of those players were on a league championship team?
There were a lot of players in the Foothill League that put up big numbers, which made The Signal’s choice for the 2006 All-Santa Clarita Valley Baseball Player of the Year a difficult one, but only one player answered the first three questions — Valencia senior Casey Mulligan.
Mulligan wasn’t the best hitter in the league — he wasn’t even the best hitter on his team.
But he was dependable at the plate, the kind of guy you’d want up when the bases were loaded in the bottom of the seventh inning and your team needed a run to win the game.
He got his chance, chopping a single over third base that skipped into the outfield and scored the winning run in a 2-1 victory for the Vikings over league-rival Canyon May 3.
Mulligan hit .402 with a home run and 21 RBIs, getting on base nearly 50 percent of the time.
But the recent Valencia High graduate’s true value was behind the plate.
It would be tough to argue that there was a better defensive player in the league.
Mulligan, possibly the best defensive shortstop in the league in 2005, made the switch to catcher in 2006.
It wasn’t until February that he was actually putting on the catcher’s gear.
But he was a quick learner, mostly because of an intimidating arm.
Mulligan threw lasers to second base after the last warm-up toss from the pitcher.
Most of the other catchers in the league displayed a dip in their throw — not Mulligan.
Runners in turn and opposing managers respected his arm and usually would not send their runners.
On top of all of that, Mulligan was a closer.
In 10 games, pitching 14 2/3 innings, the recent St. Louis Cardinals draftee allowed zero earned runs, striking out 23 batters with one of the hardest fastballs around.
His gutsy performance in the team’s CIF-Southern Section Division I second-round 12-inning playoff loss to Agoura further proved his value.
Though he surrendered the winning run, Mulligan came out from behind the plate to pitch the final 5 2/3 innings.
Imagine how his legs felt afterward.
As a four-year varsity starter, he was a leader of a team that won a school-record 25 games in 2006 and finished 14-1 in the Foothill League.
So what about the other top Santa Clarita Valley players that made the choice difficult?
When a player hits 12 home runs and hits nearly .400, it’s hard to argue against him.
John Hay from Canyon did just that.
For that production, he was a close second to Mulligan.
Mulligan had teammates in Michael Hur, Justin Shults and Nick Pappas who put up big numbers and made huge contributions to the Vikings.
But say Valencia doesn’t have Mulligan.
Say the Vikings have an average catcher behind the plate — someone who hits in the bottom of the order instead of the top.
Runners run with more success against the Vikings.
There’s less to fear when facing the Valencia lineup.
And a deep pitching staff loses its depth.
That’s the difference that makes Casey Mulligan the 2006 All-SCV Baseball Player of the Year.
