It’s an acronym that will, in the coming months, become a much more familiar part of the vernacular in Santa Clarita: MRF.
It stands for “material recovery facility,” and those who bandy it about pronounce the acronym, “murf,” like “Smurf” without the S.
But this is no cute little blue cartoon character. It’s a piece of the recycling puzzle that might be a bit messy, but can get a very important job done.
What is a murf — or MRF — and why will we be talking about it so much?
A MRF is a facility where recyclables are sorted and diverted from landfills. There are two basic kinds: Those where all trash is sorted and either shipped off for recycling or to be dumped in a landfill (a “dirty” MRF), or those where just commingled recyclables are sorted.
As Santa Clarita considers the requirements of its new trash contract, which is going to be put up for an open bidding process, there appears to be a consensus that the trash company or companies that get the contract will need to operate a MRF to ensure that Santa Clarita meets state waste diversion and recycling guidelines — something the city has failed to do under the existing contracts with Waste Management Inc. and Republic Consolidated.
The question is, does it matter where the MRF is located?
City consultants have already indicated that it doesn’t matter, but they are studying the question and will report to the City Council before it decides whether to require a MRF to be located in the city under the new contract.
Those who advocate placement of a MRF within city limits contend it will better enable the city to “control” recycling and be “100-percent responsible.”
As noble as those sentiments may seem, we don’t necessarily agree with the logic. As of yet, no one has cited an actual tangible public benefit to locating a MRF within city limits.
In fact, a MRF can easily be equated to a mini-landfill, a purgatory for trash awaiting shipment to its final destination. It’s difficult to imagine a MRF being considered an attractive neighbor for most city residents and businesses.
More likely, it seems the reason for placing a MRF within city limits might simply be to tailor the contract proposal to benefit one hauler over another. If the city “requires” a MRF to be developed within the city, it will make bidding on the contract a great deal more costly for haulers that would otherwise plan to use their own MRFs at existing landfills. Don’t bet for a second that City Council members aren’t being lobbied heavily by those who would directly benefit from a local MRF requirement.
What’s ironic is, some of those very same council members fought long and hard to prevent a dump from being developed on the outskirts of town, in Elsmere Canyon. That mega-dump would have eclipsed a MRF in size and scope — but essentially, a MRF would be a mini-landfill right here in town.
As we’ve said, the bid process should create a level playing field for the bidders, including existing and non-existing haulers — and with the greatest possible public benefit as the primary goal. The city should get the best combination of service and price, period.
It seems to make sense for a MRF be utilized under the new contracts. But we don’t see how it makes much difference where the MRF is located — unless the real purpose is to help tilt the bid process in the direction of a favored hauler.
It will be interesting to see what the city’s consultants think. But under no circumstances should the council “require” that a MRF be developed within city limits unless it can be demonstrated with certainty that such a requirement will bring substantial public benefits that outweigh any negative impact of having it within the city.
After all. A MRF may serve an important purpose. But it won’t be cute.
