Closing arguments have finished in the case brought about by jilted investors in the would-be Elsmere Canyon landfill, officials said Thursday.
An attorney representing Virginia Langford and a group of 19 investors said the arbitration hearing between her clients and Browning Ferris Industries, the company that owns the canyon, concluded Wednesday and they expect to have a decision within a few weeks.
The plaintiffs allege BFI and the BKK Corp., which sold the land to the trash giant in the early 1990s, committed fraud when the two companies agreed to the property purchase, and willingly defrauded the dump’s investors.
“It all comes down to how the arbitrators interpret the contracts,” said Heleni Suydam, one of the attorneys hired by the plaintiffs.
Langford wasn’t available for comment Thursday.
A three-judge panel heard the case and the judges have 30 days to return a decision.
Suydam said Langford, 81, is asking for $5.2 million for the estimated profits lost, plus unspecified punitive damages.
Langford is the widow of Osborne Langford, one of the original landfill planners. She filed a lawsuit in October 1998 alleging BFI and BKK colluded to kill the Elsmere landfill project to benefit BFI’s stake at its nearby dump, Sunshine Canyon. The lawsuit was amended in February after a racketeering allegation was added.
The city of Santa Clarita spent millions of dollars in the early 1990s to defeat BKK’s proposed 190-million-ton landfill. The project was stymied in 1995 via joint legislation by U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., and U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, R-Santa Clarita. In 1996, President Bill Clinton signed the bill banning the transfer of national forest land for the purpose of establishing a landfill.
Greg Loughnane, BFI’s Los Angeles district manager, had no comment on the case other than to say the company is waiting for the decision.
BFI used Elsmere in February 2001 in attempt to lure the Santa Clarita City Council into giving it the city’s $135-million trash hauling contract. The company offered the coveted canyon in exchange for a long-term contract. The council balked at the offer, but ended up putting the contract out to competitive bid more than a year later.
BFI, along with current haulers Waste Management Inc. and Republic Consolidated, are expected to bid on the contract.
Mike Mohajer, manager of environmental programs for the Los Angeles County Department of Public Works, said Elsmere Canyon is still on the county’s siting plan for a landfill, and will be on there until the plan is amended.
Suydam said even if Langford is victorious, she doesn’t have plans to develop the property.
“It doesn’t feel realistic she would try to do something with the area,” she said. “(Langford) just wants to be compensated fairly for her investment.”
