ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Student players suffer when coaches don’t play fair ball

An SCV father recently asked me to write about his son’s disappointing high school varsity baseball experiences. It’s important to the dad that this be addressed; he needs some closure on a subject that has been painfully close to his heart.

It all has to do with the quality of coaching. While many coaches in this community are solid leaders who effectively impart skills and confidence in their players, there are some who lack significantly. Not only do they fall short as mentors, they are also non-motivating, unfeeling and unjust.

Although I have heard such complaints from parents at several schools, this column offers a glimpse into one coach’s style.

A hard-working student athlete, the father’s son maintained a GPA between 3.8 and 4.0 and gave all his might to supporting his team. This wasn’t always easy, especially since part of high school was spent watching the dad battle cancer, but mainly because his playing time and self-assurance were at an all-time low. He’d spent most of his senior year warming the bench.

This young fellow had gone from being a starting player to being brought in every couple of games for one or two at-bats.

“Mercy turns,” his mom called them under her breath.

From the bench he was expected to root for the team and high-five every player when they came in, seniors and juniors alike. He was expected to clean the field for games in which he rarely played. He was expected to fund-raise. And he did it all with commitment and sincerity.

Every now and then when he was sprung from the bench, he’d step to the plate knowing full well he’d be pulled the second he hit a pop fly or grounded out. The coach rarely subjected anyone else to the same benching criteria, though — particularly those more “favored” boys with whose families he was on friendlier terms.

Funny, the dad thought. If anyone should understand the components behind performance anxiety and would want to help ease it, it should be a mature male coach, right? Not this one.

As time went by, the boy’s spirit eroded. The pop flies and ground-outs started to replace what had been exceptional plays in the outfield, solid hits and scoring across the plate.

The ultimate disappointment took place at the senior game, the last high school baseball game of his lifetime.

Before the game the mother said to the dad, “He won’t be sitting it out today, right? No coach would do that.”

Their tension soon gave way to disbelief. All the seniors started except their son. In his place in the outfield the coach put a junior, someone with a batting average significantly less than their boy’s. Owing to the team’s overall less-than-stellar performance that season, this was a game that didn’t even matter in terms of rankings. It made no sense.

Throughout the game his folks watched the other parents in their bittersweet glee as their grown boys played high school ball together for the last time. They looked at their son, the only senior in the dugout. They watched him jump up and cheer each time one of his buddies came in.

Out of the whole senior game, he got to hit one ball in the sixth inning. No surprise, it wasn’t a great hit, either.

They read his face. His unmistakable sadness burned within their hearts.

This had been such a talented ballplayer, a starter on every team he played on beginning from age 9. He once hit homers and stole bases; he ran so fast his team had nicknamed him “Smoke.” Those legs got him chosen for intramural track competitions. Once a top draft pick in Little League, he played travel ball throughout California and neighboring states. He participated in Junior Olympic baseball, serving as team captain in the 2000 Arizona games. Baseball had been a large part of his life.

Other parents who knew him “when” saw what the kid had going. They knew he had potential — that is, before the imposed stagnation ensued. The decline began and grew under this coach.

Those parents had also complained among themselves about the coach’s methods, his treatment of this boy and of other players, but they never let their words go further for fear of a backlash.

When the senior game ended, the unhappy mom and dad decided to talk to the coach. All those games they’d kept their mouths shut, fearing their son would pay the price if they spoke up. Well, those days were over.

“How could you do this to our son at his last game, a game that didn’t even count?” the mother asked. “How could you stick him in for a couple minutes toward the end?”

With arms folded defensively across his chest, a perturbed look on his face, the coach sharply replied, “’Cuz I wanted to win.”

“Look,” the mom said, “we know our son’s playing is not what it used to be, but there are reasons for that. He never gets to play. What you are saying here is that at the last game for seniors, it was OK keep him in the dugout and put in an 11th grader. I ask again, how could you?”

The coach paused for a moment, then blurted, “I wanted that other player to get some experience.”

“On Senior Day?” both parents exclaimed.

“That other boy has a year to go here!” the father declared.

He questioned the coach’s ethics as well as the accuracy of certain team statistics. He told the coach he’d called the scorekeeper on one occasion to check on numbers he felt might be askew.

Hearing this, the coach’s face turned crimson and his body tightened.

“Just who do you think you are, bothering my scorekeeper?” he snapped at the father. “I heard all about that. I know you called.”

“Hey, I had a right to call,” the dad responded. “This is my kid.”

The mother quickly summed up the situation and announced her theory: Her son’s treatment on Senior Day was in part payback for her husband questioning the stats. She knew, as many parents of school athletes do, that if you question the “powers that be,” you risk much.

Then came a shouting match between the coach and father. The mother walked off, believing the situation hopeless.

Soon after, both parents left the field with their son, for good.

After a sigh of relief, the son hugged his folks. “I’m going to try to focus on college now and put this behind me,” he told them. “Thanks for coming and supporting me — and my team. I just wish it all had been better.”

Ironically, the following week, just before graduation, that young man was named student athlete of the year — one of the highest academic awards bestowed upon high school students from the California Interscholastic Federation.

Not bad for a bench warmer.

Now with high school over, the teen and his folks reflected on the entire season. They recalled how from the outset that coach emphasized his desire to develop all of his players, not just win games.

Even those who were not directly punished by being benched failed to develop as much as they hoped to, and most played far below their potential. The team grew dysfunctional under a leader who instilled envy and competition among teammates.

A school that had the tradition of championship seasons quickly became a losing team and a whipping post for a coach who criticized them for their defeat while taking victories for granted.

Coaches who blame the team for failures without looking at their own leadership, who let good players wither on the vine, are like mosquitoes: They suck the passion right out of our aspiring athletes.

Today there are young players in our schools who will never make it to college ball or the pros, not because they don’t have the talent and drive, but because they have coaches who abandon them. These instructors fail certain players by not caring enough to develop their skills and work on their weaknesses. They fail them by not being impartial and empowering.

The standout players who wind up in the paper do not necessarily speak for all the talent on a team. Unfortunately our coverage, any coverage, will never tell the complete story of who has busted his butt at practice, trying to prove to a coach who already has his favorites selected, that they too deserve equality and grooming.

Funny ... and to think this is all about a game.

So ends the story for the father who wanted me to write about his son’s disappointing varsity baseball experiences. I just couldn’t say no to the man.

After all, the player is my kid, too.

Diana Sevanian is a Signal staff writer. Her column appears Saturdays and she can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].

← Back to 2002

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:989.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,481 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [Signal staff; Signal staff writer; [address]]
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: SCV]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 4, national 0