If it saves one life, it’s worth it.
That’s what most educators are saying about Every 15 Minutes, a locally sponsored program that tackles the issue of teen-age drinking and driving — and its consequences.
But some take issue with the “shock value” of the program.
Every 15 Minutes makes the rounds at two local high schools each year, addressing the junior and senior classes. During the two-day event, students volunteer to participate in a simulated drunken driving crash, taking on roles of the driver and those who are killed or injured in the wreck.
Several other students volunteer to be randomly selected throughout the day to be taken out of their classes by a sheriff’s deputy dressed as the Grim Reaper. Their obituary is read over the school’s public address system signifying another death from drunken driving.
The driver of the simulated fatality is taken to jail while other “victims” are taken to Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital or the Los Angeles County Coroner’s office, where those who died get a look at a body bag... from the inside.
The students are held in a hotel room overnight to write letters to their parents about people they are going to miss now that they have died. Then, at an assembly the next day, students read the letters to the upper-grade classes.
The program heads to Canyon and Hart high schools this school year, but one Canyon teacher says the program has an adverse impact on the students.
Social studies teacher Andrew Smith wrote a letter to The Signal last month stating that the Every 15 Minutes program is “potentially harmful and very disturbing to the kids.”
Smith’s letter said there is very little data to support the program’s effectiveness, and urged parents to have their children opt out of school during the day the program is offered.
Smith has not returned The Signal’s calls seeking additional comment.
Deputy Mike Shapiro, community liaison for the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station, promotes and produces the program. He agrees the program is shocking, but believes it is the only way to reach the teens.
“Death in itself is very shocking and disturbing to everyone, but we are showing the kids death and bringing them back. We want them to understand how death feels without having to go through it,” he said.
Shapiro said all the participants share their feelings later that night, including the two students who were placed in body bags.
“If you die in a car collision you will be placed in a body bag,” he said. “The kids do say how creepy it is and how it felt, but all five kids involved in the crash have a huge part and they need to share their different experiences.”
All the volunteers are given options on whether they want to be in a body bag, fly to the hospital in a helicopter or go to jail, Shapiro said, and they are given as much information as possible on what that is going to feel like.
Parents who volunteer also have some hurdles to overcome as they write obituaries for their children. They have to be officially notified of their child’s “death.” Shapiro said some parents have requested the death notification be given at their place of business so fellow employees are also impacted by the program.
“The experience brings the parents closer to their child,” he said. “Kids now know they can talk to their parents and the parents are more assertive and take control of what’s happening in their child’s life. It is very painful. They don’t ever want to have to write their kid’s obituary.”
Every 15 Minutes would cost as much as $75,000, but several organizations donate their services and many use the opportunity to train for emergency situations. Shapiro said he spends about $8,000, using the funds for T-shirts that are given to all juniors and seniors.
“So much is donated,” he said. “Everyone from the tow truck company donating the two vehicles involved in the crash, ambulance service, coroner’s office and all the emergency services personnel.”
Canyon Assistant Principal Bill Bolde said there are probably many teachers who share Smith’s beliefs, but there are more who support the program.
“I’m hearing it’s working,” Bolde said. “What I see from the students (who participate) is there is a genuine desire to do anything they can to make a difference with their friends, their peers and the whole concept of helping students learn not to make bad choices.”
Bolde was the athletic director at Saugus High School when softball player Lauren Blaire was killed by a drunk driver in 1999. Blaire’s parents have attended the Every 15 Minutes programs at the schools to speak to the students about their daughter and the impact on the family when someone is killed by a drunk driver.
“Lauren’s death affected me and the entire population at Saugus High,” Bolde said.
q q q
Protests were heard at Hart High School the first year the program came to the campus in 2000. Some teachers took exception to the shock value and had concerns the program was not reaching enough students.
“We wanted an alternative program that would include more students,” Hart counselor Coleen Flaherty said.
Flaherty agrees with Smith that the program is grim and the shock value only works for a short period of time. Counselors have dealt with families that have truly gone through a tragedy and the pain is unbearable, she said.
“I’m not saying there isn’t a problem with drinking and driving — there is,” Flaherty said. “I just don’t like the shock effect and all the other things that goes with (Every 15 Minutes).”
Assistant Principal Maria Lacy coordinated the program at Hart High two years ago and said the assembly was very moving for the kids, but it’s difficult to get students and their parents to volunteer.
“It’s a big buy-in for the parents and they have to agree to do a lot, including writing the obituary,” Lacy said.
But, Lacy and Flaherty agree that if the program saves just one life, it’s worth it.
Shapiro said he has heard many of these complaints over the years, but has statistics to prove the effectiveness of the program. Juvenile driving-under-the-influence arrests have gone down 62 percent since 1999, the first year of the Every 15 Minutes program, he said.
“This is very difficult to measure,” Shapiro said. “How many kids haven’t done something because of this program?”
q q q
Barbara Oliver and her daughter, Tiffany, then a junior at Valencia High School, participated in the program in April. She said the program was explained to her and she was sure she knew what to expect.
“The emotions take you by surprise,” Oliver said. “There’s knowing and there’s knowing. You know you have to write that obituary and it’s just kind of a sobering moment. It’s hard to imagine that you would have to do that for real.”
“When the deputies showed up at my door that day I said, ‘I know it’s all pretend,’ and then I burst into tears.”
Oliver said the reason she agreed to volunteer for the program was for her kids.
“You talk to your kids for years about not taking drugs and how they shouldn’t drink and drive. This program hits them where they live. It touches emotions in a way that opens up an opportunity for the parents to talk to their kids,” she said.
Oliver’s 21-year-old son Jeremy graduated from Valencia in 1999. While his class did not have the program come through their school at the time, he said watching his sister take part in Every 15 Minutes was sobering.
“When I heard my sister’s obituary and watched her get up and say goodbye, it made me think twice (about) drinking and driving several times,” he said. “I’m 21 now and can legally go to bars. My friends and I always have a designated driver. If not, we know to call someone.”
q q q
According to Shapiro the number of deputies assigned to traffic has remained the same since 1999 with the addition of two motor officers.
Capt. Don Rodriguez attributes the decrease in juvenile drunk driving arrest to the message of the program.
“It brings an awareness of the awesome responsibility involving our young people,” he said. “It’s an opportunity for us to interact with the students in a positive way.”
Rodriguez said he is amazed when he sees high school students who have never spoke to each other before, embracing and becoming friends.
“It breaks down barriers,” he said. “Our young people have seen so many gruesome things on the ... news and in the movies. We think it’s a valuable program.”
q q q
Drinking and driving is not the only subject the program tackles.
Alice and Tom Renolds of Canyon Country lost two sons in a 2000 crash: They were riding in a car driven by a friend who attempted to pass another vehicle at an excessive rate of speed. The car hopped the center divider on Soledad Canyon Road and smashed into an oncoming vehicle.
Tim and Danny Renolds were students at Canyon High School when they, along with fellow Canyon student Nick Ianozzi, were killed, as well as motorist Rodney Adams, who was on his way home from the gym.
Speed, not alcohol, was the fatal factor in that crash.
Tom and Alice Renolds have appeared at the Every 15 Minutes program to speak to students and their parents about reckless driving.
“I think the program is getting to some of those students,” Alice Renolds said. “Every time we’ve spoken we have had students come up to us afterwards and say they’ve been touched and thank us. You just never know how many others you’ve affected.”
Renolds said the shocking nature of the program is important because teens need to see how real it is.
“They always have that ‘it’s not going to be me’ attitude. ‘I know what I’m doing,’” she said. “When they see their friends in (the crash) and how it affects their family, it hits them.”
Alice Renolds tears up when she remembers her sons and the heartache her family has endured.
“It’s important to me to talk to the kids, and if I’ve saved one life by talking to them, I will continue no matter how hard it is. I don’t want any parent to ever have to go through this,” she said.
Bolde said about 50 Canyon students have already volunteered to participate in the program in December. He met with parents of those students this week to explain the commitment.
He said he hopes to get the number of students participating in the program down to 20 and have representation from every student group. Students who do not wish to participate during the program will be allowed to opt out.
“It’s a good program and it is working,” Bolde said.
Shapiro said people remember traumatic things and he wants these kids to remember.
“They remember where they were at 8:46 on Sept. 11. Adults remember where they were when Kennedy was shot,” he said. “When it’s time to take a drink and get in a car, we want them to remember what happened at Every 15 Minutes.”
