Two Santa Clarita grocery stores are scheduled to be acquired by Haggen’s Food and Pharmacy, a small chain of 18 stores based in the Pacific Northwest.
The Vons Pavilions on McBean Parkway in Valencia and the Vons grocery store on Bouquet Canyon Road in Saugus are two of 168 stores the Federal Trade Commission has required be sold before it approves the merger of Safeway, the parent company of Vons, with Albertsons LLC.
As a result, Vons and Albertsons stores will close across five states, including the two in Santa Clarita and one Albertsons store in Palmdale on West Avenue North. The FTC requirement is to prevent one grocer from controlling too much of a single market.
Four other existing Santa Clarita Valley Vons and Albertsons will continue to operate under the Albertsons name, but the merger brings an end to the Vons name and grocery stores.
The offer
While there are four final offers, Haggen’s agreed to acquire the bulk of the stores - 146 stores in five states, Washington, Oregon, California, Nevada and Arizona.
Comvest Partners, a private investment firm, is providing Haggen the capital to finance the deal, but terms of the deal haven’t been disclosed.
The purchase agreement is subject to approval by the FTC and the transaction is expected to close in early 2015.
“The FTC can change, reject or modify any part of the proposed transaction,” said one local industry source. “If history is any example, the FTC has changed terms of deals whereas the locations to be divested may not meet what the FTC requires.”
On the other hand, because Albertsons found a willing buyer with Haggen to purchase a large grouping of stores, that sometimes changes the FTC’s divestiture methodology if the FTC can keep a large grouping of stores together under one buyer, he added.
Plans
Haggen’s intends to convert all of the stores it acquires in the first half of 2015. The grocer, based in Bellingham, Washington, plans to retain current store management teams and a spokesperson said store employees will have a chance to become Haggen employees.
One local industry source questioned whether such a small regionalized grocery chain could manage growing from 18 stores to acquiring 146 stores almost overnight, speculating part of the deal might be part of a real estate investment for the locations where ground leases could be sold.
And there is the question of how Haggen’s will be able to manage stores spaced so far apart over five states.
Haggen’s
“We committed to this acquisition because we knew we had the experience, talent and drive to get it done,” said John Caple, chairman of the Haggen board of directors and partner at Comvest Partners, a private investment firm that owns the majority of shares of Haggen.
A spokesperson for Haggen’s admits it is a large deal and said the next 100 days will be very busy, but believes the grocer won the deal because it put together a detailed plan and has great people onboard to execute it.
The company will be led by CEOs John Clougher and Bill Shaner. Shaner, CEO, Pacific Southwest, will have primary responsibility for the southern division of California, Nevada and Arizona.
As for those shoppers already frustrated by the ongoing changes in product lines at Vons as a result of the Albertsons acquisition, the Haggen deal potentially represents more disruption for local shoppers. An executive, however, sought to reassure customers.
“We are a full line store and we plan to have a core assortment that customers will find meets most of their needs, and will supplement those with products that are locally relevant. Being locally focused is a core value of Haggen,” Shaner said. “We plan to be on the ground and although the stores are spaced apart, we are still small enough to be very nimble and responsive to each store’s customers.”
Haggen’s signed an agreement with United Grocers, the largest wholesale grocery distributor in the western United States, to be the primary and preferred supplier for all of Haggen’s new stores.
The United deal creates a ready supply of products for local stores, and represents about $750 million annually in new business for the distributor.
Still, there are other obstacles to overcome, according to a local industry source.
A Big Task
Haggen’s will need various licensing approvals in California such as liquor, pharmacy, food storage and handling, etc. The licenses do not automatically transfer. And while it can all be done, he wonders how long it will take and at what cost.
“California is not a very business-friendly state to do business in; except for doing business in Santa Clarita,” he said.
A bigger challenge, however, is labor.
In discussions with two of the seven labor union presidents in Southern California, their opinion is that Haggen has no choice but to accept existing labor bargaining agreements, the source said. That means Haggen’s cost structures will be higher compared to non-union operators.
“I want Haggen to succeed, but my bottom line analysis is that acquisition is too large for the small Haggen to manage over a large geographic footprint,” the source said.
While Haggen’s does have some mountains to cross, if the grocer pulls off the conversion it will benefit from a built-in customer base to a degree.
“Locally Fresh”
Shoppers tend to be just as loyal to locations as they do to brands, and if the two Santa Clarita Vons stores are en route to and from work or school, shoppers will continue to shop at the new Haggen’s out of convenience.
Founded in 1933 in a little Bellingham store, the grocer supplies its stores by using small local farms – some 39,000 of them in Washington alone. It also helps to support local fisheries, ranches and wineries in the Northwest.
If the grocer manages to extend this tradition to the local market, the “Haggen Northwest Fresh” slogan could be a hit with local shoppers.
One Seattle resident said she loves the homemade bakery products and fresh fish market in her store. Santa Clarita residents should really like having a local Haggen’s in their market, she said.
“Both long-time customers and new customers really love the Haggen experience. They appreciate our commitment to source locally and give back to the communities where we have stores,” said a spokesperson for Haggen’s. “We are excited to introduce more people to the Haggen experience.

