Santa Clarita Valley residents are already adjusting to a statewide minimum wage increase from $8 to $9 that went into effect earlier this year. So far, those in Northern Los Angeles County have remained on the outside of minimum wage talks going on at various city levels, but unfortunately, that may change soon.
In March, the L.A. County Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to commission a study of the impact of a minimum wage increase for county workers, employees of county contractors and workers in unincorporated areas – which includes communities in the SCV like Stevenson Ranch and Castaic. The report would be carried out by the L.A. Economic Development Corporation (LAEDC).
The Valley Industry & Commerce Association (VICA) commends the supervisors for seeking a study before drafting a proposal. However, VICA predicts that the results will reflect those of a recently released study by Beacon Economics of the effects of a citywide minimum wage increase in the City of Los Angeles.
The Beacon study concluded that not only would a citywide minimum wage increase to $13.25 or $15.25 an hour by 2019 diminish L.A.’s competitive edge, but that its intended application is too broad to lift those who truly need help out of poverty.
For example, the plan does not take into account total compensation, including tips, commissions and other monetary benefits. Some have urged the supervisors to consider exempting tipped employees in any plan to raise the minimum wage, but a different wage for tipped workers requires a change in state law.
Because of factors such as these that L.A.’s plan fails to take into account, Beacon found that less than one in four dollars paid out via the city’s plan would go to those it is intended to help – the young and the low-skilled. A minimum wage increase for the city of L.A. will be paid by consumers through higher prices, businesses through reduced profits, and workers who are laid off as a result. There’s no reason to believe the same wouldn’t be true for L.A. County.
While the supervisors have not yet laid out a proposal, LAEDC will begin its study by reviewing the results of the Beacon study and the two others released concurrently.
The study, proposed by Supervisors Sheila Kuehl and Hilda Solis, will look at the potential effects that would stem from raising the minimum wage to $13.25 – a full 47 percent. It will also examine the ways such a wage increase might cause jobs to shift around the region, any changes to the population that relies on public assistance, and the overall fiscal impact on L.A. County.
The troubling results of the Beacon Economics study should be of great concern to businesses and residents in L.A.’s unincorporated areas.
Just 2,500 of the county’s 96,000 employees make less than $13.25 an hour, largely because employees begin at the entry level then receive raises as they develop new skills. But such an increase to the minimum wage would cause a dangerous ripple effect throughout the L.A. area. County employees across the pay spectrum would inevitably ask for raises once their contracts went up for renewal.
There are also 7,700 licensed businesses in the unincorporated L.A. County area whose labor costs could go up significantly, forcing many to cut hours, jobs, or close their doors entirely. Those businesses would be unable to compete with their neighbors in the city of Santa Clarita.
VICA applauds Supervisor Michael Antonovich, who insisted the study look at whether the shift would send economic activity out of the region. A spike in the minimum wage could force companies to raise costs, sending consumers to neighboring counties to purchase products at lower prices. Employers may also resort to cutting jobs to compensate for higher labor costs, leaving hardworking people out of a job.
L.A. County will hold hearings to allow business owners to express their concerns regarding a potential minimum wage increase. VICA awaits the results of the coming study of the impacts of a minimum wage increase for L.A. County, and will continue to act as a voice for the business community in future conversations on the issue.
The Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA) is a business advocacy organization based in Sherman Oaks that represents employers throughout the Los Angeles County region at the local, state and federal levels of government.
