Emmett C. Murphy researched and wrote “Talent IQ,” a ten year study of over 100,000 leaders. The purpose of the book was to learn how to identify top performers, improve or remove underachievers and how to increase both productivity and profits for companies.
There are three truths business leaders need to face.
The first is there is a war for talent. Most companies seek “A” and “B” players which is one reason why hiring takes longer than in the past.
The second is that companies believe that they have the luxury of waiting to select the best and will not risk hiring someone not in the top tier. However, as the war for talent intensifies, time will work against organizations failing to move fast enough in the hiring process. The candidates will chose to go to competitors.
The third is that considerably more is expected from those on the payroll. Companies see payroll as an investment in the future, not recognition of the past.
“What have you done for me lately?” is thought about often by leaders, and it is now said aloud. “A” and “B” players can always answer the question. The remaining employees will struggle to reply.
Many CEOs, owners and top executives are in denial and do not think that they have employee on their payroll who would struggle to reply.
I believe every organization has individuals Emmett refers to as being “on the bubble.” This refers to individual job behavior and is defined as any behavior that can compromise the achievement of the company mission.
These are people known as “on board bombers” or “internal terrorists.” Most of the time, leaders ignore the behavior, hoping that it will simply go away.
The ostrich approach to human resource management is a serious mistake because bad behavior is encouraged by silence. Silence is acceptance.
Left unaddressed, the undesirable behavior creates two unwanted results. First, it undermines the morale of high performers; they move on to other employers. Second, others may adopt the behavior, creating more underperformers and internal terrorists.
By conducting an informal survey of top performers, the truth will surface. Simply ask those in the top tier of leaders to identify the top three challenges or opportunities facing them in their jobs.
Emmett says that “if compensation for poor performers or the results of their work” comes up more than thirty percent of the time, your company is in trouble.
Underperformers typically go through five stages, from fence-sitting, avoidance, hostility and contempt to outright irresponsibility. The path for this behavior ends in what Emmitt calls “professional suicide.”
Can someone be turned around and if so, how can it be achieved? It requires courage and it requires action. In Emmitt’s own career, he was taken to lunch by his mentor who said to him, “Your recent actions? Stop it. You are a much better person than your behavior suggests.” Emmitt did; forever grateful.
Telling someone that they can improve is a deeply caring activity and a sign of true responsibility. The problem is the leaders that need to act this way often run from it.
When do you make the decision to release someone for a new assignment elsewhere? The answer is when you no longer have a positive expectation that an individual will be a contributor to your company.
This is not a sudden decision; the person in question has left a trail of evidence that clearly demonstrates it is time for them to move on.
The decision comes down to risk; the impact to customers; to colleagues; to shareholders, the ones who will carry the load if the person continues to stay on the payroll.
Ken Keller is the CEO of Strategic Advisory Boards. Strategic Advisory Boards guides leaders to their desired future through use of peer perspective, best business practices and leadership tools while reducing risk and unnecessary expense. For a complimentary leadership assessment, please visit www.strategicadvisoryboards.com/. Keller’s column reflects his own views and not necessarily those of The SCVBJ.
