As a recently retired CPA who has studied the tax law and its history for years, I find that Donald Trump’s tax proposals look like Voodoo economics on steroids.
A couple of years ago, I took a class on alternatives to the current tax system. As I recall, if we went to a flat-rate tax and eliminated all deductions, to be revenue neutral the rate would have to be around 24 percent applied to every dollar of gross income.
The rate would be much higher if certain deductions, such as home mortgage interest or charitable contributions, are retained.
The Trump plan would apparently retain both. That means the average tax rate under the Trump plan would have to be significantly higher than 24 percent.
The top individual tax rate under the Trump plan is 25 percent, but that would only be paid by individuals making more than $1 million per year.
So the individual tax rate changes certainly are not revenue neutral.
But it doesn’t end there. Mr. Trump wants to reduce corporate income taxes to a mere 15 percent from the current 35 percent rate. Globally, many countries have cut their corporate tax rate to the 25 percent range in hope of attracting corporate business activity and job creation.
But the dirty little secret is countries that have cut their corporate tax rates have funded those cuts by increasing taxes paid by individuals.
A good example of this is Denmark, which recently cut its corporate tax rate from 40 percent to 24 percent. However, Danish individuals pay 15 percent federal income tax on the first $6,500 of income and 37 percent on everything over $6,500.
In addition, there is a provincial income tax of 15 percent. Denmark has very few deductions, so this is pretty much a flat tax at a 52 percent rate.
In addition, Denmark has a value-added tax (a type of sales tax) of 15 percent on all goods and services.
The Danish situation illustrates the price individual taxpayers have to pay to fund a 25 percent corporate tax rate. Besides Trump, several candidates, including Jeb Bush, have said they want to reduce corporate tax rates.
Tax proposals may make for great politics, but when you dig down into the details, many are not that feasible. Trump’s proposals are a fine example of that.
