An investigation into claims that county supervisors tried to influence planning processes, going against their own policy, revealed little, but left some Santa Clarita Valley activists suspicious.
After being fired in January 2009, former Los Angeles County Regional Planning Director Bruce McClendon claimed it was because he had told his boss he’d seen Board of Supervisors’ aides intruding on the planning process.
He said the elected officials’ aides tried to influence planning staff, going against county policy.
In response, supervisors ordered an investigation, the results of which were made public Friday.
The firm Harvey M. Rose Associates, which was paid about $70,000 to conduct the investigation, could not substantiate any of the allegations. However, they noted that three of the charges raised questions about county policy and procedures.
Mostly, a lack of evidence left McClendon’s claims unprovable — which Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich spokesman Tony Bell was quick to point out.
“There was no ‘there’ there,” Bell said. “The allegations were found to be unsubstantiated.”
Antonovich’s Board Deputy Paul Novak features prominently in the report, along with several aides for other supervisors.
In the report, Novak denied doing anything wrong.
The report says Novak shouted at McClendon at a meeting for not providing him with a copy of draft legislation about water availability in new developments before it was brought to the board.
McClendon said Novak wanted to review and approve the legislation before staff presented it, which would go against the board’s non-intrusion policy that was adopted in 2007.
“...no individual member of the board, nor any deputy or assistant to any member of the board of supervisors, shall give orders to or instruct any county officer or employee, but may seek information and/or seek assistance from county officers and employees,” the policy states.
Novak said he was angry because deputies are routinely given draft staff reports so they may brief their board members, and he was frustrated because he wasn’t able to do that, the report states.
In another instance, staff was working on a drought-tolerant landscaping ordinance. Novak asked staff to change wording at Newhall Land Development Inc.’s request.
“Please add in (Newhall Land)’s language,” Novak wrote in an e-mail to planners.
The report notes “there could be some debate as to the extent to which these quotes are directive.”
County Auditor-Controller Wendy Watanabe chalked the saga up to a miscommunication.
“In the end, that’s the bottom line,” she said. “The non-intrusion clause was unclear. It wasn’t very well-defined.”
Watanabe recommended to the board last week that they amend the ordinance for clarity.
“There’s enough ambiguity there that it resulted in this gray area and these allegations. Especially when it comes to legislative issues, the governing body, our supervisors, they have to have the ability and opportunity to communicate with departments.”
For environmentalist Lynne Plambeck, president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, the report shed light on a troubling county process that heeds developers’ words more than the public’s.
“It’s disturbing to me that the developers in our valley have so much access to the planning process,” Plambeck said, noting that residents have three minutes to speak on items at meetings while developers give entire presentations. And now this report shows that developers have input through much of the process leading up to those meetings, too.
“It’s interrupting good planning,” she said.
And although the claims were shot down, with county staff saying they have no knowledge of the events McClendon claimed had taken place, some Santa Clarita Valley residents view county government with suspicious eyes.
“To me, (the report) didn’t really resolve anything in my mind. To me, it just said, ‘Don’t be a whistle-blower,’” resident activist Cam Noltemeyer said.
Still, Bell was nonplussed.
“The public knows very well that when someone makes allegations there are many reasons why,” he said. “This report was done by a thorough and independent eye, and the investigator found no merit to the allegations. There’s little to take away from it.”
