The Topps trading card company is taking a giant step forward in the card collecting hobby, and a giant step back. Both steps— forward and back— are intriguing.
The step “back” is in its 2001 Topps Baseball 50th Anniversary Archives card series. Topps announced the big step back by reminding us that “you stuck them in your bicycle spokes, you flipped them with friends and then your mother threw them out.” Boy, can we relate.
Well, the step back is this new series of baseball trading cards which uses the “images” of Topps’ classic cards during the past 50 years of their production. “Topps has reprinted the rookie and final season card of each of the 100 featured players (the 100 most memorable players)... As a bonus, Topps is also featuring the opportunity to pull the 100 original rookie and final year cards.” So what Topps is apparently doing is reprinting these great cards but also is inserting in some packs the actual original cards. It’s another of the so-called “ buy-back ” programs.
Buy-backs is when a card company goes into the open market, buys back the original cards, to insert them in a current product line.
Topps also plans to have some of the star players autograph their buy-back cards including Duke Snider, Willie Stargell, Robin Roberts, Jim Palmer and Carlton Fisk. “Each card has been autographed and is hand numbered to 100,” making them more collectible.
Each eight-card pack sells for $3.99 and one autograph card (unnumbered autograph cards) is in each box of cards.
The big step forward for Topps is a deal it struck with Professional Sports Authenticator, a company that grades cards for quality and wear (bent corners, bends, etc.) and seals the cards in tamper-proof plastic cases. Graded cards, as they are known, are meant to provide collectors with authentication as well as an independent third-party appraisal of a card’s quality.
The three-year agreement between Topps and PSA, which is owned by Collectors Universe of Newport Beach, provides for Topps to provide PSA with certain cards for grading. These graded cards will be made available for sale through card dealers and shops.
Fleer and Upper Deck, two other sports trading card companies, also market “graded cards.”
Collectors Universe also owns the Professional Coin Grading Service which grades coins and seals them in tamper-proof plastic cases. Recently, an PCGS-affiliated company started to grade and seal in plastic postage stamps. Other companies in the collectibles industry are in the same market and others even grade and seal in plastic such things as paper money and comic books.
Some collectors highly respect and demand the independent third-party grading, while other collectors want no part of it.
It is a controversial issue among collectors.
Some collectors say some dealers and collectors are more concerned with the “grade” that appears on the plastic case, known as the “slab,” rather than the coin or other collectible inside the slab. These critics of the industry claim that the grading services are not objective in their grading, and give preferential treatment and higher grades to some collectors and dealers. All of the grading services maintain their independence.
The “slab market” as it is known is widely used on such Internet auction sites as eBay, providing collectors with some assurances with what they buy. The Internet is also known as the “ sight-unseen market” and third party grading and encapsulation is one way to assure buyers and bidders that a coin or stamp or piece of paper money has not been “ over-graded ” by its seller. In the collectibles business, over-grading is akin to cheating a buyer by claiming an item is worth more than it really is.
The best advice for any buyer or bidder is to view the item in person and to make a knowledgeable appraisal of its condition and value. When an in-person inspection is not possible, third-party grading and encapsulation is the next best thing.
Remember, all third-party grading standards are not the same, and all values are not the same. That is to say, a coin graded as a Proof-69 (out of a possible high score of 70) with one grading service might no command the same respect and price with one grading service as with another. Collectors should familiarize themselves with the marketplace reaction to each grading service’s reputation.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
