ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

By Alan Mendelson

Auction cheats and the shill police

Auctions have never been more popular.

There are weekly auctions at auction houses selling everything from fine art to household items to overstocked merchandise from factories and stores.

There are Internet auctions that are all the rage and have spawned stock market behemoths such as eBay. There are other companies that have recognized the popularity of auctions and have branched out to this segment of the market, companies including Collectors Universe of Newport Beach and Yahoo! and Amazon.com.

Unfortunately for the consumer, each auction may have its own rules, and the various rules could put buyers and sellers at a different advantage— or disadvantage.

Bid padding is the issue

The issue comes down to the auction company’s tolerance, or approval and support, of bill padding, also known as shill bidding.

A shill is someone who bids on his own auction to get the price moved higher. Another form of this kind of bill padding is for the seller to create a second secret identity also with the goal of bidding up the price on his auction, including an auction item that was consigned to a third-party auction company.

Still another type of shill bidding is for the seller (or consignor) to arrange for a friend or relative to place a higher bid on something that is up for sale with the purpose of forcing another bidder to pay more.

Some auction companies do not allow shill bidding or bid padding. Others allow it but point out that if the seller or consignor of the item is stuck as the high bidder, then that person is also liable to pay the auction fees.

Protective bids

Various auction companies allow for “protective bids” so that their lots are not sold at prices that are too low. Some bidders consider protective bids unfair and an invitation to shill bids.

The online auction site eBay used to allow each seller to have one bid of their own lots, but eBay has since changed this rule because it concedes that the rule was “abused and so it had to be eliminated.”

Coins Plus, in Newhall, allows one “protective bid” on its bid board auctions of coins, stamps and other collectibles. The bid board allows sellers to post items, either with a minimum bid or at “open” with no minimum.

The store allows one protective bid by the seller just in case the bidding doesn’t go as planned. This bit of insurance protects sellers against low turnouts or a lack of interest that could otherwise result in a very valuable item selling for as little as 10 cents.

Some nationally-known auction firms also allow protective bids, but with a caveat— the seller who wins his own auction will pay the fees for the auction. Many auction companies charge sellers a commission of 10 or 15 percent, and they also charge buyers a commission as well.

The Michael Aron Rare Coins company is a well known auction company, and it charges a 10 percent buyers fee in addition to the seller’s fee.

“Consignors may be permitted to bid on their own lots. In all cases, a commission would be charged for any re-acquisitions ,” the company’s auction catalogues read.

Facing the prospect of paying a seller’s fee and a buyer’s fee for bidding on one’s own lots is a consideration before any protective bid is made, yet sometimes it becomes necessary.

Shill police

The decision by eBay to stop protective bids gets wide support among members of the Internet news group rec.collecting.coins— and this group is known for following certain auctions and for finding auction abuse and finding shills. You might say this news group has a lot of “shill police.”

Here are some of the things that the “shill police” look for:

• The same bidder who shows up exclusively in the bidding for one seller. This, however, is not proof of a shill. Even eBay cautions that it is not unusual for one bidder to bid exclusively in the auctions of one seller— though it is a bit unusual.

• A bidder who shows up with a bid in the final seconds of an auction. This could be the sign of a shill who is trying to keep an item from selling at a price that is too cheap.

• A bidder who places a bid in the very first few minutes of an online auction. This could also be the sign of a shill because it is very unusual for a bid to be made until several hours after an auction is first listed in an Internet site. This is because it usually takes several hours— sometimes eight hours or longer— for an auction to show up in the Web site’s directory of auctions. The only bidder who might know of an auction so quickly is the seller himself.

• A bidder without a record of winning any auctions at all is another sign of a shill. Shills will place bids along the course of an auction but may not bid high enough to actually win the lot. Also, these shills can sometimes prevent themselves from winning the auction lot by withdrawing their high bid at the last possible moment.

As I pointed out, different auction companies have different rules about shill bidding or protective bids. They are allowed by some companies, and bidders should know what the rules are before raising their bids.

Of course, shill bidding and protective bidding would not be needed if sellers and consignors of auction material set a minimum bid amount that would make them happy to begin with.

But some sellers believe that auctions will build momentum and bids will go higher with auctions that start with no minimum. If true, there would not be such a thing as a shill or a protective bid.

But sometimes the open bidding process does work very well, even though the final moments of an auction can be scary.

It happened to me about a week ago when I put a rare coin up for sale on eBay. The bidding for this coin languished at about half of its true value for nearly nine days that the auction was on eBay. But then, in the last three minutes of the auction, five bids were placed that raised the price on the coin to a level that not only exceeded my expectations but had me laughing with joy.

I must admit, five minutes before that auction ended— and just two minutes before that rush of bidding— I was contemplating how I could place a shill bid even though I would have been an eBay cheater.

Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .

Image not recoveredmugmendelson_alan.jpg

← Back to 2000

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/mendelson/0500/053100.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,147 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_business
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/2 mentions: Valencia, Newhall]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Personal Finance]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 7, national 0