For the past six months, ever since they were first released by Wal-Mart stores, those Sacagawea golden dollars were mere curiosities. Few, if any, ever made it into circulation, and most were scooped up by consumers and collectors and socked away into dresser drawers and keepsake boxes.
But now it’s time to go back to those coins you stashed away for a second look— a good hard, second look. And now it’s time to go to the bank to pick up a roll of 25 coins or more if you can afford to, and give those coins some good hard looks as well— because the golden dollars are now more than curiosities. They can be big money.
Coin collectors are now discovering all sorts of valuable errors on the new golden dollar coins, and these errors can be much more valuable than that plethora of errors that was discovered on the 50-State quarters that were released about a year and a half ago.
One of the rarest of the error coins— a dollar that was minted with the front from a Washington quarter on it— sold on the eBay auction site Friday for $41,395.
There are three other similar coins with this major goof, referred to as a “Sacagawea dollar muled with a quarter dollar coin,” and some coin experts believe that as these others also come to market prices could rise substantially.
And the experts believe there are more of these coins waiting to be discovered from rolls and bags of the dollar coins now sitting in banks and at the Treasury and the Federal Reserve.
And while you’re looking for the “mule” coin, don’t forget to look for many other errors that are more common with values ranging to several thousands of dollars.
Here’s more about those special rarities:
There are now two types of golden-dollar error coins that could be worth big money. The hottest of the error coins right now is a Sacagawea golden dollar coin that was minted with the front of a new Washington quarter. Because the Washington quarter design is smaller than the surface of the golden dollar coin, there is an extra rim around the quarter design that is struck on the golden dollar blank.
So far, four examples of this type of error have been discovered. The fourth coin was confirmed to exist on Wednesday.
“But there might be more out there that haven’t been discovered yet,” coin expert Ed Grundy of Superior Stamp and Coin in Beverly Hills told me.
Superior is one of the nation’s top and biggest coin auction houses. Grundy says it is likely that three or more of the Sacagawea dollar coins with the Washington front or “obverse” are yet to be found. It is unlikely, he says, that all of the goof coins could be found so quickly. It is also possible that the mint’s high-speed machines stamped out many of these coins before inspectors at the mint found them and recovered them.
Error coin expert Fred Weinberg of Encino figures that the mule dollars are likely to gain in value as more of the coins are put up for auction and publicity and interest grows in the coin collecting community.
Made on purpose?
There also is speculation that the coins were made “accidentally on purpose,” meaning that the mint engineered the error coins, arranged for their striking, and for a few to be salted in different shipments. Why? Well, to increase demand for the coins. The mint says they were made strictly by accident, when a worker put the wrong die (the die for a quarter) in a mint press making the dollar coins.
But those who support the “conspiracy theory” point out that there are millions of golden dollar coins sitting in bank vaults waiting for consumer demand and acceptance. What better way to get consumers to go to banks to demand the coins then to create a frenzy for valuable error coins? The conspiracy theorists say millions of consumers could flock to banks to buy rolls of the coins hoping to find an error, and then spending the coins without errors.
Millions of government tax dollars are at stake in this golden dollar program. You’ve seen the government’s television ad campaign trying to boost acceptance and use of the coins. The vending machine industry has also invested big bucks in the dollar coins which are intended to be a better coin for consumer use than the Susan B. Anthony dollar coin was.
The golden SBA dollar
That brings us to the second type of major golden dollar error: a Susan B. Anthony 1999-dated coin stamped on a blank for a golden dollar. Superior Stamp & Coin in Beverly Hills has one in its possession— on consignment from another dealer, and it will be put up for auction soon. Only two of the SBA-golden blank coins have been discovered so far.
Ed Grundy estimates that the golden-SBA might bring $120,000 at auction, and he concedes there also might be more waiting to be found in bank rolls and bags.
Grundy believes that the bidding for the Sacagawea-Washington coin could have been subdued because collectors fear that many more of that type error coin could be found and that would keep prices from exploding.
Older error coins with low “populations” can fetch the highest prices because as time goes on it becomes more likely that new examples of the old error will be found.
Other errors, too
Error coin dealer Fred Weinberg in the past few weeks has assembled a collection of golden dollars with other significant errors, including:
• A golden dollar coin without any design on the front or back, worth $175.
• A golden dollar coin that was struck twice, with the second strike on only half the coin, worth $2,500.
• A golden dollar coin that was struck with the reverse upside down, worth about $500.
• A golden dollar coin that was struck on a “washer” — a metal ring used to hold nuts and bolts together. Value, $10,000.
• A golden dollar coin that was struck on a clipped planchet or “blank.” Its value is about $250. Coin experts can tell the difference between a partial blank that was struck with a coin design and a regularly struck coin that was cut away after it left the mint.
Most expensive error coin
As of now, the most expensive error coin minted by the United States is the 1943 penny in “copper.” Yes, pennies are generally in copper, but in 1943, because of the war and a shortage of copper for the World War II effort, steel was used instead for making cents. Somehow, 18 cents (pennies) were struck with copper, and the most valuable of these recently sold for $115,000.
If you have a 1943 cent that appears to be in copper, don’t buy a Mercedes and plan a European vacation until you have the coin checked out. There are many counterfeits and many “steelies” that were plated with copper.
One test you can perform at home is this: See if your copper cent is attracted to a magnet— and if it does, sorry, you have a copper-plated steel cent. If the cent does not stick, you could be rich.
Steel pennies from 1943 are worth about 15 cents in circulated condition, and they are worth a couple of dollars if in bright, uncirculated condition.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
