“Getting caught is the mother of invention.”
— Robert Byrne
Next time I get reincarnated, I’m coming back as a public utility.
They make all the money. It seems inmates from seven states are suing several phone companies over the high cost of reaching out and touching someone.
Get this. In Indiana, AT&T charges $3.95 for prisoners to make their initial long-distance hook-up , then it’s 69 cents a minute after that. Sorry. No discounts for calling on weekends or after 7 p.m. So, if you’re making a simple 3-minute call to your attorney, homey (homie? ho-mee ?), pregnant girlfriend or a simple outreach bomb threat to the D.A., it’s going to cost you six bucks.
Prison and officials say the outrageous prices are necessary to defer cost for the security measures. Plaintiffs in the seven states say it’s price gouging. They point to Nebraska— and, before we go on reading this column, let us all take a moment to point toward Nebraska; it’s due east— where they only charge 19 cents a minute to make a call from the poky.
Class action suits have been filed in Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, New Mexico, New York, New Hampshire and Wisconsin. Illinois took in $6.3 million in prison pay phones and New York a whopping $25 million. Interestingly though, California made $24 million, but is not yet named in any lawsuit. These states have a commission system where they can rake in as much as 56 percent of every call.
Nebraska seems rather kind-hearted , with one prison official, Steve King, noting: “We don’t want to make money at the expense of inmates.” I suppose also, being Nebraska, inmates don’t have much to talk about.
“How’s the cows?” asks Bubba, reaching out and touching someone.
“Oh. Fine. Might cholicy,” says his bride.
Long silence.
“Cornhuskers got new uniforms this year?” asks the prisoner.
“Don’t think so, Bubba.”
“Well. Didn’t think so. Gotta go.”
“Bye now.”
I personally don’t have any problem with charging Charles Manson for calling the Led Zeppelin hotline. As a ruthless bottom-line Republican, I wonder if say California’s $24 million is profit or just on paper because how do you collect on Charles Manson’s phone bill? I mean, if he doesn’t pay, what are you going to do? Throw him in jail?
Then, you’ve got the problem with the short-timers . There’s this woman in Indiana, Selena Kingsley, whose husband was serving four years on drug charges. They ran up their phone bill to over $7,000 (I’m guessing that’s about 20 minutes of talk time). Mrs. Kingsley said the bill ruined her financially and she still owes the phone company money.
It’s sort of a de facto tax because most of these prison phone kickbacks go back to the states for everything from polishing the state capitol dome to making their computers Y3K compliant.
“It’s gouging and profiteering,” said Stephen Seliger, the Chicago-based lawyer who has filed class-action lawsuits not only against three states but the Corrections Corp. of America, the company that runs 70 prisons nationwide.
Of course, speaking of gouging, if lawyer Seliger wins his multi-million-dollar lawsuit, well kids. I think you can do the math on what 40 percent of several million dollars is.
Hijinx with telephones and prisoners is certainly nothing new. A few years back, some jailbirds in Texas were put to work doing phone solicitations. Texas sub-contracts part of their prison system and private enterprises are under contract to care and secure that state’s hard apples. Being capitalistic— which doesn’t necessarily translate into being bright or ethical— these companies saw dollar-signs on the faces of their charges. They paid them a few pennies a day to take catalogue orders.
Yes. I know. You think you’re calling an indifferent operator at Acme Mail Order Garden Supplies but really, you’re giving your Platinum Visa number to Claude the Fraud. Thousands of people were rather livid when they discovered that they were giving sensitive credit information to convicts, who were then passing this info on to cohorts on the outside who were then running up people’s plastic to dizzying heights.
Now the crazy thing is, if you’re a utility or corporation, it’s perfectly legal to attempt to defraud the American people via small print and obfuscation. But let a convict do it and we start making all these operatic, swooning sounds. Now, the states and baby Bells are trying to, ahem, to paraphrase the prison vernacular, ‘date’ the convicts in the shower by charging them outrageous phone fees.
Oh well.
At least the inmates don’t have to suffer from having MCI or AT&T calling them at dinner time, urging them to change their long-distance carrier.
John Boston’s Mr. Santa Clarita Valley column appears Wednesday through Saturday. To reach Boston, dial 259-1234 , ext. 242.
