With the presidential campaign in high gear, all sorts of political memorabilia are rising in value among collectors.
Some of the memorabilia is indeed rare and was handed down from generation to generation, including campaign material from Abe Lincoln’s run for the White House.
But some of it was fished out of trash cans and dumpsters and is now very valuable. Collectors are scooping up and “bidding up” what they can get their hands on. Old buttons, bumper stickers and badges from conventions are the winning ticket for making a profit now.
Case in point: an ID badge shaped like a medal on a ribbon from the 1960 Democratic Convention in Los Angeles that chose John F. Kennedy as the presidential candidate. That badge is now valued at $150. And bumper stickers from the 1960 campaign are worth about $3 each. In your heart, you wish you had kept some of those “ AuH2O-Goldwater for President” stickers.
Valley View Coins and Collectibles in Encino is doing a brisk business nationwide, buying and selling political memorabilia. Buttons are highly sought-after , with buttons sporting pictures of the candidates from a century ago the most in demand.
A William Jennings Bryan button from 1896 is valued at $60, while a JFK button that flashes from a portrait to the phrase, “A Man for the 60s,” is priced around $20. Condition also counts— buttons in the best condition command the highest prices. But be careful about modern-day reproductions.
Modern-day buttons can also command a premium. An anti-Jimmy Carter button that says he is doing the job of three characters (the Marx brothers) is valued at $6. Ronald Reagan buttons are popular in California because Reagan is so popular.
JFK memorabilia follows the Kennedy mystique. A plastic hat from 1960 is worth $30. It’s probably as valuable as it is because few were saved, and very few survived in pristine condition. Remember that with political memorabilia as with art and coins and stamps, condition counts.
New definition for ‘ugly’
Speaking of condition: It’s now been several months since I put two of the new Sacagawea golden dollar coins into my pocket change. I’ve kept those same coins all this time so I could see how they would be affected by daily use. I’m now able to report on their appearance.
They look UGLY. In fact, as the old joke goes, they could put a picture of the Sacagawea dollar in circulated condition next to the word “ugly” in the dictionary to illustrate what the four-letter word means.
My two coins have lost all of their golden color. Now, they are a dark mustard-yellow and resemble game-room tokens. The designs are still clear, with no significant damage to the details of the portrait of Sacagawea on the front or the eagle on the back, and the lettering and numerals are not affected by wear. But that lack of damage to the portraits, illustrations, lettering and numerals is what you’d expect to see on a coin that is designed to last three decades in circulation.
If the U.S. Mint designed the golden dollar coins to be attractive gold coins, the strategy is a miserable failure.
But unless you kept a couple of coins in your pocket all the time, like I did, you probably wouldn’t know that, because the golden dollar coins are not circulating.
Sure, Wal-Mart has been giving millions of them out in change, and they are available at many banks, but it seems that the coins are immediately going into drawers, bottles and keepsake boxes and they are not circulating.
On some Internet news groups, consumers and coin collectors are discussing some of the reasons why the Sacagawea dollars are not circulating. Here are some of the theories:
• The golden color. While there is no real gold in the golden dollar coins, some consumers actually believe they do have some gold content, so they believe they are worth more than a dollar.
• The mint’s retail price. The U.S. Mint has been selling rolls and bags of the coins to collectors and the general public at a premium over their face value. So, consumers getting the coins are led to believe that they are worth more than their face value, and they are not spending them.
If the mint really wanted to get these coins into circulation, the mint should have sold them to the public at a discount— say 99 cents for each $1 coin. The discounted price would prove to the public that they are meant for spending and not for hoarding.
• The lack of circulation. The mint has been criticized for its plan of giving the first few million coins to the Wal-Mart chain for distribution. Again, this increased the sense that the coins were special. A more widespread circulation program would have lessened the feeling that the coins were special.
• The Cheerios promotion hurt. The Mint also made a deal with General Mills to make the Sacagawea dollars available as prizes in special boxes of Cheerios cereals, again misleading the public into thinking the coins were valuable.
The Coinstar survey
Coinstar, the company that operates those change-redemption machines in supermarkets and stores has surveyed the public about their perceptions of the new dollar coin.
The survey showed that about half of the Americans surveyed have at least one of the dollar coins, and they are reluctant to spend them. Sixty-six percent of Americans say they will keep the coins they get. Seventy-two percent of women say they’ll hold on to the coins, while 60 percent of men say they’ll hold on to them.
Coinstar also found that 69 percent are more likely to keep using dollar bills instead of the new dollar coins.
Coin collecting boom
One thing can’t be disputed: The new golden dollar coins and the new quarters honoring each of the states are creating millions of new coin collectors. That’s healthy for the coin collecting hobby and for the business with coin values— especially values for older Washington quarters— shooting up.
But there’s a downside to the new collecting boom: A threatened coin shortage is developing, with banks and retailers reporting that quarters are in short supply. It makes sense, since the new state quarters are being hoarded in rolls and in bags.
Maybe it’s a good thing that the Susan B. Anthony small dollar coin never caught on, or else the banks and retailers would be reporting a shortage of dollar coins as well.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
