The “one size fits all” nature of the city’s sign ordinance has long worried business owners in Santa Clarita, especially those who rely on prominent signage to help overcome challenges like otherwise obscure or out-of-the-way locations.
Apparently, those businesses should still be worried. Very worried.
The city Planning Commission voted Tuesday night to order the destruction of the Santa Clarita Athletic Club’s electronic message sign, which flashes messages about the gym to motorists entering and leaving the Santa Clarita Valley along Interstate 5 at Calgrove Boulevard.
Maybe the dog days of summer represent a slow time of year for city staff, or perhaps our government has decided to crack down on signs throughout the city. We hope neither is the reason for the Gestapo-like action taken by the commission. But we’re having a hard time figuring out how a commission full of Republicans can be so involved in restricting free enterprise. What happened to minimizing regulations so businesses can prosper, providing jobs and economic benefit to the community?
The commission gave club owner Ronald Hamilton 15 days to tear down the sign. Considering that the sign predates the city’s incorporation in 1987 by a long shot, the compliance period is unreasonably short— and leaves Hamilton precious little time to appeal the decision to the City Council.
The sign ordinance variance and appeal process was established last year in response to concerns by business owners who worried the sign ordinance failed to adequately take into account the unique needs and circumstances of specific businesses. That was a healthy step in the right direction by the city.
Business owners’ concern was warranted, and the variance/appeals process seemed like a reasonable way to address some of those concerns while still preserving the original intent of the sign ordinance, which was designed to prevent excessive “sign clutter” in the city.
Never mind that “sign clutter” shouldn’t be confused in importance with the real issues of the day: Traffic safety, crime, school overcrowding, real environmental matters, parks and the overall question of growth.
The athletic club relies heavily on that sign, as a unique part of its business and a key means of communicating to existing and potential customers. The sign was there long before the athletic club owned the property— it was originally a sign for an auto dealer at that location. The sign has been there for three decades and it isn’t hurting anyone.
The club’s location is distant from the valley’s core commercial areas, and the sign has allowed the business to maintain the visibility it needs.
Certainly, such message-board signs aren’t universally loved, but the practical matter is the sign is an important part of the athletic club’s efforts to promote itself. If you take away the sign, you’re making it substantially more difficult for that particular business to succeed.
It would be one thing if the city were prohibiting such a sign from being constructed in the first place. But in this scenario, the city is ordering the destruction of a sign that has long been an important part of a business.
The sign ordinance was adopted in 1990, and a 10-year grace period was included to allow businesses time to use previously existing signs and replace them over time. However, the city made little or no effort during the first nine years of that grace period to keep businesses informed of their need to comply.
Then, last year, the warnings finally started to come. As one might expect, many businesses were surprised, due to the fact the sign law had received virtually no publicity for a decade. The deadline for compliance was Nov. 13.
When the variance/appeals process was established, it was presented as a means for businesses with unique circumstances to have those circumstances taken into account before the city orders signs to be removed. This is just the sort of circumstance that should be accommodated by that process.
Let’s hope that, when the decision goes before the City Council, the council will recognize the importance of this sign to the Santa Clarita Athletic Club— rather than making the athletic club comply with the city’s cookie-cutter approach to sign regulation.
Additionally, there are a lot of problems with the city’s sign ordinance, which should be amended to take out more teeth. It is far too restrictive. It addresses a problem that is hardly among the most important issues facing this city and this valley.
This is ostensibly a pro-business , pro-free enterprise council. We hope their appointed planning commissioners would be of like mind.
