One of the biggest complaints I have heard from mutual fund investors over these past several months is that their fund managers did not insulate them from this great stock market downturn.
Since its March 10 peak last year, the tech-laden Nasdaq composite fell nearly 60 percent until it just recently rallying back some. This took all of the tech and tech-stuffed growth funds down with it.
Cash would have been a warm, dry place during that monsoon, and as investors saw their formerly high-flying funds crater, a debate raged, prompting the question: Why don’t stock fund managers cash out of stocks when they’re in a free-fall ?
Answer: By and large, stock funds aren’t designed to avoid losses at all costs or hop in and out of the market, trying to time its ups and downs. Rather, they’re designed to own stocks and try to beat a benchmark, like the S&P 500 for instance, through savvy stock picking. That means stock funds typically keep 90 percent or more of their money in stocks whether times are good or bad, trying to gain more than a benchmark on the upside and lose less on the downside.
The upshot: If you thought your fund managers’ overarching goal was not to lose your money— not an outlandish assumption— you’re wrong. Fund mangers’ bonuses and jobs depend on them gaining more and losing less than their peers and an index.
In the end, the person in charge of how much money you have in cash is you. If you thought you were for market timing, 99 percent of funds don’t do that.
In many cases, by prospectus, mutual fund managers have proscribed limits as to how they can invest stocks, bonds and cash as well as internationally. When a fund manager shifts assets out of the investment arena focus, as described by the prospectus, into another investment arena, this is called “style drift.”
Many advisors want funds to stay fully invested so they can control the asset allocation. For example, let’s say you allocate 60 percent of your investable dollars into a large-cap growth fund and the remaining assets into bond funds and money market funds— an allocation that you are comfortable with. Then you find that the growth fund manager has taken 50 percent of the assets he manages and put them into bonds instead of growth stocks. That means you really have only 30 percent of your total portfolio in growth stocks instead of the 60 percent that you were seeking. That growth fund manager could be accused of “style drift.”
So, what can you do to protect yourself from being slammed by these downturns in the market, if it is not the fund manager’s job to that for you?
• Asset allocation. Establish an allocation among different asset classes with which you would be comfortable. Different classes and sectors have varying degrees of investment risk and volatility associated with them.
Your allocation will depend upon your risk tolerance. You may want to have an investment professional help you determine that allocation. By implementing an appropriate asset allocation strategy, when a market downturn comes, not all of your investment “eggs” will get slammed.
• “Dynamic.” I believe that when a certain investment sector gets significantly overvalued (as technology did this past year), then it would be prudent to reduce one’s allocation to that sector. I call this “dynamic” asset allocation.
Instead of holding to your original allocation percentages in each sector and class (commonly referred to as “static” asset allocation), why not shift your allocation from the overvalued sector to an undervalued one or to a more defensive asset class? This requires the investor being proactive instead of being solely passive. Again, a good investment professional can help you with this decision process. I must say that there is some debate on the effectiveness of this approach but it is one to which I subscribe.
If you have any investment or tax questions that you would like to see answered in this column space, please submit them to The Signal. I, or one of my co-columnists , would be glad to respond.
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
