OK. I’ll come right out and say it:
The city should go to bid on its trash franchises.
It is not a conclusion I have reached lightly. And I mean no harm to the individuals who are close to this story. I have my regrets about saying this, and I have some friends who will be angry with me over it. That will not be easy.
But there is just too much at stake, and the public’s interest is not being served when it comes to trash, either by the current city management or by the franchise agreements that have been struck by that management.
It would be a huge mistake to renew those deals at a time when uncertainty abounds regarding the accuracy of the haulers’ waste diversion reporting, and at a time when better deals may be had, either by switching haulers or bringing greater pressure to bear on the existing haulers to deliver a more competitive package.
I’m one of those guys who considers his tax bill to be plenty high enough, thank you. So it’s alarming to me when an appointed government executive goes to an elected official and says, “I need a million dollars.”
It’s even more alarming when, upon being rebuffed by that elected official, the appointed executive runs out and creates a brand new tax so he can still get the million dollars he wants.
Sure, there are possibly pure motives and pure uses for such revenue. But dammit, we pay a lot of taxes already, and we did not form this new city to create new hidden taxes for free-spending government officials. We formed it to get better value for the taxes we already pay.
When I studied political science in college we talked about something called an “iron triangle.” It’s been a while, but if my memory serves correctly an iron triangle exists when appointed government officials, elected leaders and private business unite to protect common interests, to preserve a status quo. They call it an iron triangle because it is difficult to break, as each “side” of the triangle is a strong entity unto itself, but the three sides together form a nearly indestructible structure. Each of the three sides of the triangle cooperates with the other two with one primary interest in mind: Self-preservation . Rarely is the public’s best interest well-represented by an iron triangle.
In the past few days, we have heard much talk about the construction of the iron triangle that is our local trash service. It’s amazing what a little journalism can uncover.
We have a former trash hauler who says the city manager told him the city would bring in another hauler if the local haulers didn’t go along with a 10-percent city trash tax. We have a former City Council member who says the trash tax was borne out of the city manager’s desire to pump up local road maintenance revenues after he was rebuffed on his request that a public transit grant be sliced up to also cover roads. We have various City Council members, past and present, from opposing sides of the local political spectrum, who say they do not recall ever being asked to order an audit of the waste haulers’ numbers. And we have a current council member who says that, in fact, City Manager George Caravalho once relayed to the council a local hauler’s request that an audit not be conducted.
Whatever the city does with its trash franchises, it is clear that the process is too closed, and not enough scrutiny is occurring at 23920 Valencia Blvd. When the city staff doesn’t know— or won’t tell— what the franchised haulers pay at the landfill gate, something is seriously wrong. How can they possibly recommend that we sign those new contracts, in good conscience, when our rates are higher than other cities and they have no idea why?
Just whose interests are being protected at City Hall? I don’t think anyone can say with certainty that the public’s interests are getting top priority. Maybe if the trash franchises are put out to bid, that will change— and perhaps, then, the deal will still involve our local subsidiaries of the trash hauling giants. That would be fine, if the deal is good and the reporting is accurate. Whatever is done, it is time to restore the public’s interest as the priority. Going to bid would do that.
The iron triangle must be broken. I hope our existing city leaders are up to the task.
And what if they are not?
* * *
All politics aside, I’d like to wish a happy Mother’s Day to the very important mothers in my life, including, of course, my own Mom (who’s put up with a whole lot of my shenanigans over the years) and two moms who are expecting to be moms again in the near future: My sister, who’s due any second now to give birth to my nephew, and my own lovely bride Erin, who plans to complete the symmetry of the Whyte household by giving birth to our baby girl in July. (One mom, one dad, one boy, one girl, we’re done...)
Anyway, happy Mother’s Day to all of you.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
