During the first nine months of this year, investors poured some $68.9 billion into bond funds. This is a dramatic change from 1999 and 2000, when investors withdrew some $54.1 billion from bond funds. This change in fund flow was caused by investment dollars fleeing stocks, and money market accounts (and CDs) being a less attractive investment alternative due to such low short-term interest rates.
According to Lipper Inc., through October, the average taxable bond fund increased in value 5.59 percent while the average diversified stock fund fell 19.4 percent over that time period. As one can see, bond investors have done well this year. But will bonds continue to be an attractive investment alternative over this next year? Can it still be considered a safe investment haven going forward?
To answer these questions, consider the following.
Bonds fluctuate in value
A bond (or bond fund) can fluctuate in value for three reasons:
1. Market interest rates change. There is an inverse relationship between bond values and interest rates. As interest rates go up, bond values tend to go down. As interest rates go down, bond values tend to go up. That is why bond investments have performed very well since the beginning of this year. Since the beginning of this year, we saw interest rates decline dramatically.
2. The credit quality of a bond changes. Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s periodically rate bonds as to their credit quality. If the financial circumstances of a company should deteriorate, then the value of that company’s bond should fall in order to provide a higher interest return to investors for the increased risk they would be taking to own the bond.
3. Yield spread (yield gap) between high risk and low risk bonds. Right now, the difference between BBB+ bonds (higher risk bonds) and AAA bonds (lower risk bonds) is extremely high by historical standards. This spread expands during times of economic and financial stress because investors are more concerned about possible interest payment default from troubled companies. As economic and financial times improve, the interest rate spread contracts as investors feel more comfortable investing in higher risk bonds.
Risks and rewards of investing now
If you believe the Federal Reserve Board is close to the end of its interest rate cutting cycle, then you would have to believe that bonds may not appreciate in value much more due to additional drops in interest rates. In fact, investors may face declines in bond values this next year, if the economy should accelerate, there by forcing the Fed to begin increasing interest rates again.
Remember that inverse relationship between changes in bond values and changes in interest rates? Bond investors benefited from the decline in interest rates this year. They may lose money next year if interest rates should rise.
The credit quality of many corporate bonds (and in a few instances, municipal bonds) may worsen over these next few months as more businesses are adversely affected by this global recession. This could mean that certain bonds in your portfolio or bond fund could be downgraded by the above mentioned rating services thereby causing your bond values to decline. With continuing declines in corporate profits— expected to last at least a couple more quarters— more and more companies may soon be feeling the wrath of downgrades by bond rating services.
The only silver lining in this gloomy bond picture is that of eventual yield spread contraction as the economy starts to recover. As business and corporate profits improve, more investors will be willing to shift investment dollars from low-risk , low-interest-paying bonds to higher risk higher interest paying bonds.
When this happens, interest rates typically decline for higher risk bonds, thus driving those bond values up. But when this happens, stocks also tend to jump in value— typically moving much higher than corporate higher risk bonds. So, at that juncture, I would prefer to be in stocks instead of bond anyway.
Going forward, I would have to say that bonds may not be the safe investment haven that many believe. In fact, we may find bonds losing value this coming year as stocks increase in value. For those seeking safely, money market funds and CDs may be your only recourse— even with such lousy interest rates.
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
