Shortly after The Signal’s coverage of the Oct. 9 City Council meeting regarding the proposed Porta Bella development and toxic cleanup, we received a letter from Dick Held, one of the investors in the property owned by an arm of Arizona-based Remediation Financial Inc.
Held indicated that the newspaper’s coverage was inaccurate, and that we had mischaracterized his testimony to the City Council regarding the question of who, if anyone, promised RFI it would be allowed to develop the controversial Porta Bella site in phases.
We have printed Held’s letter here as a courtesy, but we believe the actual comments made Oct. 9— as we have transcribed from the videotape of the meeting— support the accuracy of our original story. We can only assume that Mr. Held’s recollection of his exchange with the City Council is selective. We submit that, contrary to the accusations made by Mr. Held, it is his letter that is inaccurate, not The Signal’s coverage.
In his testimony, Held said, “When we made the original investment in Porta Bella development, we went on the basis that this property was going to be developed in a phased development, allowing us to reinvest our capital, get our money out, continue reinvesting. Well, what has happened here is the city has not allowed us to do that, and basically put a stranglehold on our investment and our ability to let capitalism work here, and as a result, we have a lot of investors that are unhappy with the situation.”
All capitalism flag-waving aside, the city’s policy, as determined by the council, was not to allow phasing at the time RFI purchased the property several years ago. It wasn’t until several months later that a non-binding memorandum of understanding was reached, indicating the city would consider phasing.
Phasing, in the case of Porta Bella, is a dicey proposition because of the nature of the toxic contamination on the site, former location of a munitions plant.
Logically, Held’s statement prompted a follow-up question from Mayor Laurene Weste, and the following exchange ensued:
WESTE: Can I ask you who told you and represented that you would be able to do phased building?
HELD: In our original— I’m going to have to step back because I’m getting most of my information from the attorneys, but there was a memorandum of understanding at one time that did say that we would get phased development, and we had— can I have the— (gesturing to RFI officials) why don’t you come up here and talk with me, because I’m talking as an investor? Our agreement was that we were going to get phased development in exchange for giving you access (for Golden Valley Road construction). That was the deal, and it’s like buying a house and agreeing to pay $200,000, and somebody coming back and saying, “No, now I want $300,000,” or something to that effect.
WESTE: Thank you.
HELD: You guys changed the deal -
WESTE: OK, thank you for answering my question.
HELD: What?
WESTE: Thank you for answering my question.
HELD: OK.
Held seems to have forgotten a few things: When RFI made the initial investment in the property, the MOU did not exist. And even when the MOU came into play, it did so as a non-binding understanding, not a final contract.
In the end, this exchange answered few questions and raised many more. And as long-time observers of the Porta Bella mess, we simply want to know:
Did anyone at City Hall promise RFI phased development despite the fact that to do so would have been contrary to the standing council policy at the time?
It’s a puzzling question, and it seems impossible that everyone who has been involved has been wholly truthful. The trick is, figuring out exactly who has been lying— and when.
