ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

City attorney responds to open-meeting law allegations

The Ralph M. Brown Open Meeting Law serves the laudable goal of requiring the public’s business to be discussed, deliberated and decided in an open and public manner. The law allows the public and press to observe, become informed and participate in the political process. While the law requires nearly all meetings of local legislative bodies like the City Council to be open and public, it authorizes a body to meet outside the public view for specific, narrowly defined purposes, such as to discuss pending litigation, real property transactions or certain personnel matters.

Several articles and an editorial have appeared in The Signal recently relating to a closed session of the City Council that was held on Sept. 7. It appears the articles result from an incomplete knowledge of the facts and an unfortunate choice of terms on my part in discussions with Signal staff members.

The purpose of this response is to clarify the facts surrounding the meeting of Sept. 7, the advice given and actions taken at and following the meeting. At the request of the city attorney on Dec. 14, the City Council waived the attorney-client privilege and the confidential status of information related to said meeting of Sept. 7, thus enabling me to pursue this discussion.

By way of background, it should be noted that the city had for some time sought to acquire the Santa Clarita Water Co. as a municipal utility. Those efforts were unsuccessful. During much of the same time period, Castaic Lake Water Agency also sought to acquire the same privately owned water company and did succeed in working out an agreement for the purchase in August. The city opposed the purchase by CLWA on the grounds that CLWA could not become a water retailer except through contract with an existing water retailer consistent with the limitations of California Water Code Section 12944.7.

At one time the city considered challenging CLWA’s purchase of the Santa Clarita Water Co. but decided not to do so. On the first of September, four taxpayers initiated litigation seeking to overturn CLWA’s purchase of the water company, raising arguments consistent with city positions.

On Sept. 7, the City Council met in closed session pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9 (c) to consider initiating litigation by joining in the taxpayers’ action either by intervention as a party or by amicus curiae (friend of the court). It is our opinion that the closed session for these purposes was appropriately placed on the agenda and is entirely consistent with the Brown Act.

The council rejected initiation of litigation either by intervention or by amicus participation. As an alternative, the council on a 3-2 vote authorized that a legislative analysis of Water Code Section 12944.7 be made available to the taxpayer plaintiffs and directed that the city attorney monitor the taxpayer action. That legislative analysis, which was the subject of the attorney-client work product privilege, was obtained by the city for possible use in litigation if it had been pursued against Castaic Lake Water Agency challenging the purchase of the Santa Clarita Water Co. to become a retailer. Since the determination was made by the council to abandon the potential litigation, the legislative analysis was deemed to be no longer a confidential document protected by the attorney-client work product status. As such, the effect of the council’s action was to release the document as a public record subject to disclosure which was then available to anyone, including the press or any citizen requesting it pursuant to the Public Records Act (Government Code Section 6250, et seq.). Accordingly, even though the city paid $800 for the legislative analysis, once it was outside the exemption of attorney-client work product, anyone could obtain a copy of it for the cost of duplication simply by making a public records request. Furthermore, since it was available to anyone, making it available to taxpayer plaintiffs did not amount to funding their lawsuit.

As previously noted, my “monitoring” activities consisted of not more than three brief telephone conversations with the taxpayers plaintiffs’ counsel as to the status of the taxpayers’ action. There was no review of pleadings or advice given by me relative to the pursuit of their lawsuit. Unfortunately, in early discussions with Signal staff members, the term “consulting” was used by me to describe one of the directions from the majority of the council in their alternative actions at the Sept. 7 closed session. That term, on reflection, could indicate a review of pleadings, advice and recommended actions in relation to the plaintiff taxpayers’ action. None of these activities took place or were intended. My activities in relation to the taxpayer action were to keep track of the events in that litigation and report to the council. The phone calls to the plaintiffs’ counsel consisted of information being provided to me regarding the status of the case. There was never any meeting between me and the plaintiffs’ counsel. Reports were not made to the council regarding the litigation because events were brought to their attention by press reports, so there was no need.

One of The Signal columns and the editorial of Dec. 19 concluded that actions taken by the council on Sept. 7 were equivalent to “intervention.” Had the council decided in closed session to intervene in the action, the Brown Act would have required that decision to be disclosed to the public following the closed session.

Intervention is a legal term with a precise meaning as set forth in Section 387, Code of Civil Procedure. Intervention only occurs by the filing of a complaint in a proceeding seeking leave of court to intervene in another action. It is a legal process which requires the filing of a formal pleading and service upon all parties to the existing proceeding. No intervention was authorized by the City Council at their meeting of Sept. 7. Therefore, there was no decision made by the council required to be disclosed under the Brown Act. (Government Code Sec. 54957.1)

It was also reported in a Signal column that council members have been advised that it is somehow illegal for them to discuss what goes on in closed sessions. No such advice has been given. They have been advised that disclosure by a council member of confidential information which was discussed in closed session may under law be a breach of fiduciary duty. A breach of fiduciary duty involves a violation of a trust, a duty of faith and confidence owed to the entity for which the party is a trustee. City council members are trustees of the city.

The litigation exception to the Brown Act exists for the purpose of protecting against disclosure of information which may be prejudicial to the legal position of the city. In commenting upon the need for confidence as to matters discussed in closed session, the California Attorney General, in an opinion at 80 Opinions Attorney General 231, 238 stated:

“Furthermore, if individual members of the board were to decide for themselves what aspects of such information could be disclosed without prejudicing the position of the agency, the protection of the litigation exception would quickly break down. This is particularly true where a legislative body is divided over the issue of being litigated, with some members supporting a particular course of legal action (e.g., initiating, defending, or settling) and other members opposed. Board members cannot feel free to discuss the issues candidly with counsel if they believe that their disaffected colleagues will be unconstrained talking publicly about the closed session deliberations and thereby prejudice the course of action to be taken.”

Among the actions which could be taken under law against a city council member who breaches a public trust by public disclosure of closed session information are: barring the person from future closed sessions; obtaining an injunction against the person’s public disclosures; or filing an accusation against the person for “willful or corrupt misconduct in office.” (80 Opinions Attorney General 231, 140.)

A prior attorney general’s opinion reached the conclusion that a public disclosure by a member of a city council of confidential information from a closed session could result in a misdemeanor prosecution for violation of Government Code Section 1222, Willful Omission to Perform Duty (76 Opinions Attorney General 289.292). It is submitted that an effective prosecution of a council member of an unauthorized disclosure of closed session confidential information is an extremely remote possibility.

Please do not interpret this response to indicate that any public official should be immune to fair comment and criticism. The reason for the free press clause of the First Amendment, after all, is not just to protect the press, but to make it responsible for informing the public about government activities. It is obvious The Signal takes its constitutional responsibility seriously. As a lawyer and an advocate, it is expected that there will be disagreement with some of my opinions, especially from lawyers who serve as advocates on behalf of their clients, be they litigants or even members of the press. Such disagreement and discussion based on a full understanding of the facts and law is welcomed and encouraged. The First Amendment and open meeting laws are valuable to the community and we believe should be actively pursued and harmonized with the attorney-client privilege. Hopefully that can be accomplished via full and active discussion based on a clear understanding of the facts.

The opportunity provided by The Signal for responding comments to the various articles and the editorial on the issue of the Brown Act compliance is very much appreciated.

Carl K. Newton is Santa Clarita’s city attorney.

← Back to 2000

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/guest/0100/010200.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,601 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
  • byline:staff_marker [Signal staff]
  • text:valley_names [4 distinct/13 mentions: Santa Clarita, Castaic, City Council, Castaic Lake Water]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 9, national 0