For the record, I am entirely neutral on the issue of school uniforms. I in fact own a school uniform; a snappy forest green golf shirt from my beloved Sierra Vista Junior High School, which I have accessorized properly with khaki trousers to wear during some of my visits to that august institution of learning. As a neutral party, I feel I can see both sides of the issue, and the reasons both for and against said uniforms. However, Nancy is not neutral on the issue.
In all of the areas in which we have lived, when the potential of school uniforms is raised in a school where our children attend, Nancy always expresses her vehement opposition to the policy.
For many years, I believed that these opinions came from a hidden, First/Second Amendment, militia streak in my Omaha, Neb., bride. But I found recently that her opposition to school uniforms comes from the fact that they result in lost opportunities. Not lost opportunities for fashion statements and self-expression . Rather, uniform policies result in lost opportunities for parenting. If not at all ages, then certainly at the elementary school level.
How is this so? Two of the articulated reasons for a uniform policy have to do with reducing label competition among students and simplifying enforcement of dress codes since everyone has to wear the same thing. The solving of these problems by institution of a uniform policy deprives parents of opportunities to parent and teach valuable life lessons to their children.
Let’s start with label competition. I think it works like this: Some people buy their children expensive clothing to wear to school. I say that it must be the parents because I don’t know many 6-year-olds who have high-paying jobs or access to trust funds. For reasons that I don’t fully understand, other children covet these clothes and nag their parents into buying the same clothing for them. I assume that the parents cave in to the desires of the children because they feel the child will be humiliated if they are not able to maintain the hip label that all the cool kids are wearing.
I am not certain about these things since I have an 11-year-old who wears a T-shirt and denim shorts from Sears 365 days a year, an 8-year-old whose clothing comes mostly from Target, and a 4-year-old with half his closet from friends who have outgrown clothing worn by older children.
Now some parents might be happy to be taken off the label competition hook with a uniform policy. But what about the chance lost to parent? Valuable lessons could be taught concerning priorities. For example, parents could explain that the family takes the money saved by purchasing moderately priced clothing and puts it toward a college fund, extra payments on the mortgage, or a family summer vacation. Also, a priority could be that expenses need to be managed so one parent can stay at home, or another parent does not have to work as hard and can spend more time with the children. In this way, the children learn that there is more to life than just competing on the basis of possessions, something that will serve them well in the future.
Now on to the subject about dress code compliance. Every school has a dress code that forbids the wearing of certain clothing that is deemed inappropriate by contemporary standards. Currently, most codes forbid the wearing of gang-type clothing by males and particularly revealing clothing by females. Still, there are violations of which I am sure that the parents are aware, unless the kids are buying the inappropriate clothing for themselves and changing into it somewhere between the drop-off curb and the front door of the building.
What a valuable opportunity to teach a life lesson in following standards! In the future, when the child is going for the big interview to that entry-level job, they will realize that there will be a consequence if they show up wearing baggy pants and tattoos. Also, almost all jobs require the workers to wear appropriate clothing within a certain range, whether they be professional, white collar, or in one of the crafts. Of course, the child will be taken off the hook if they enter one of the proud professions where a uniform is required, which would include a nurse or law enforcement. However, these professions require discipline and self-control that may not have been learned in grade school, so they may be relegated to a uniformed profession that also includes use of a spatula.
So I still say that I am neutral on the issue of school uniforms, but I must say that after hearing Nancy’s cogent arguments, I think I am beginning to lean in her direction.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
