Several weeks ago I had dinner with a longtime friend. My stomach churned as she told me of her plans to become a mother through artificial insemination. My friend is a successful career woman with an advanced degree in her field.
Though she wants to marry, she has not yet had the opportunity. She explained that she wanted a child of her own and hoped for my approval. I could not in good conscience give it. I do not deny that she has more than adequate intelligence, competence and finances to bear and raise a child. But there is one thing she could never provide— a father.
Single women raising children on their own is the latest fad. The May 28 issue of Newsweek magazine lauded an increase in the numbers of families headed by single women. According to the results of the 2000 Census, 55 percent of American households are headed by married couples while families headed by women total 11 percent, up 25 percent since 1990.
The media considers this trend a victory for women’s rights. I see it as a defeat for this nation’s children. It is disturbing to think that kids being raised without fathers is considered “normal” and even, in some cases, preferred.
The push has been, over the past several decades, to elevate the place of women in society. The results have been both good and bad. While women have become more valued, men are becoming less so, especially in the rearing and nurturing of children. In June 1999, American Psychologist ran an article entitled, “Deconstructing the Essential Father,” which stated that “parenting roles are interchangeable, that neither mothers nor fathers are unique or essential.” The authors claimed that the traditional belief that fathers are essential in the upbringing of children is no more than a “backlash against the gay rights and feminist movements.” Their campaign was to “free women from the unequal burden” of child-rearing . However, instead of being freed from child-rearing responsibilities once shared by their spouses, more and more women must now bear the “burden” of raising children and running a household alone.
While Newsweek concluded that this growing phenomenon is both accepted and common in American culture, they also pointed out that single parenthood may not be the optimum choice for children. In other words, is it good for the children? While there are always exceptions to the rule (i.e. single mothers who raise exceptional children or two-parent homes with problem kids), statistics suggest that the answer to this question is no. For example:
• Fatherless children are five times more likely to live in poverty, compared to children living with both parents. (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Center for Health Statistics, Survey on Child Health, 1993)
• Fatherless children are at greater risk of suicide. (Survey on Child Health, 1993)
• 85 percent of all children who exhibit behavioral disorders come from fatherless homes. (Center for Disease Control)
• 71 percent of all high school drop-outs come from fatherless homes. (National Principals Association Report on the State of High Schools)
• Adolescents from single-parent families engage in earlier and greater sexual activities compared with those from two-parent households. (Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 1994)
And the list goes on and on.
The trend of single-parent homes may be on the rise, but that does not mean it is good. Newsweek quoted a sociologist from the University of Wisconsin as having said, “The average kid in a single-parent family looks much the same emotionally as children who grow up in the most conflicted two-parent homes.”
Travis Ballard, President of National Congress for Fathers and Children said, “Perhaps more than any other single factor, the absence of biological fathers [in the home] is the leading cause of many of our nation’s problems, including crime, drug problems, teen violence, inner-city strife and juvenile delinquency.”
Last year, in an attempt to restore the traditional belief that fathers are just as important as mothers, California Assemblyman Robert Pacheco drafted joint resolution 44, “Fathers in the Home,” which stated that “marriage between one man and one woman is the foundation upon which the superstructure of the family is built” and that “the ideal situation for children is to have a full-time committed and loving mother and father.” It urged the president of the United States and Congress to “reject and denounce... the opinion that fathers are not necessary and essential to the well-being of children in our homes.” A public declaration of this nature would have a tremendous impact on future policy-making , would re-establish the traditional model for the family, and help sway society toward that ideal. Unfortunately, this resolution died in committee. Our political leaders’ and the media’s disregard of this resolution, as well as their efforts to convince the American public that all variations of “family” are equal, are symptoms of a diseased society infected by selfishness and apathy.
So my friend wants to be a mother. She wants to fill a void in her life. She thinks only of her own happiness, of satisfying her own desires. My friend should instead consider what the consequences of her choices may mean for her child. Sure, women can do it all. We can bear the children, rear the children, and bring home the bacon, too. But it is hard enough raising a family with two parents, let alone taking it on single-handedly — on purpose.
I applaud those men and women who, through no fault of their own, are shouldering the responsibilities of raising their kids alone, who would have chosen otherwise but are doing the best they can with the hand dealt them. And I commend the fathers in this nation who love their children and who take an active part in their lives. You are essential to your children’s well-being . Don’t ever forget it.
A thread of encouragement in a subsequent issue of Newsweek: Several readers wrote in bashing the magazine’s adulation of single-parenthood . There is hope yet.
Laurisa White Reyes is a Santa Clarita resident.
