Most customers of the Santa Clarita Water Co. probably thought the hoopla was over when their water bills started instructing them to make checks payable to the Castaic Lake Water Agency.
CLWA and the city of Santa Clarita went to war for possession of the once-private water retailer in 1999, and when the dust settled, CLWA was the winner to the tune of $63 million.
Sure, there was a lawsuit challenging CLWA’s ability to act as a retailer, but the judge threw it out of court days after the sale went through. And that was the end of it. Or so it seemed.
The lawsuit is on appeal, and CLWA officials decided they needed to “clarify” the law that’s at the heart of the legal challenge.
Late last year they went to the original author of the water law, a San Diego-area Assemblyman, and asked him to introduce a new bill spelling out the ability of water wholesalers, like CLWA, to operate retail divisions, like Santa Clarita Water Co.
The bill, AB 134, started to wind its way through Sacramento. In April, between legislative committees, it was changed from a bill affecting all state water wholesalers, into a bill affecting only CLWA.
It sailed through the Assembly on a 77-0 vote in May, and now it’s in the senate.
Chances are, you never read about it until the last couple of weeks. That’s because CLWA never told anybody what it was doing.
The CLWA board never voted to direct staff to ask the Assemblyman to introduce the bill. The CLWA board never voted to endorse the bill when it became CLWA-specific . The CLWA board never voted at all— not until after the Assembly passed it and the bill landed on the desk of Sen. William J. “Pete” Knight.
CLWA General Manager Robert Sagehorn said he “had a blanket understanding with the board that we would seek legislation favorable to the agency.” This begs three separate issues.
One, we elect board members to make decisions in the best interests of the public. They shouldn’t abrogate that responsibility to staff, especially on an issue as big as the operation of the agency itself.
Two, even though most CLWA board members would probably agree with seeking the bill, maybe they wouldn’t have. How do you really know without a vote? Sagehorn’s “blanket understanding” is far too broad.
Three, if the bill had made it onto a CLWA board agenda, the public would have known about it, and the community would have been able to weigh in. That did not happen.
Sagehorn said he didn’t “have a good answer” for why it didn’t happen.
The public can’t help but be suspicious when a local governmental agency operates behind a veil of secrecy. You easily jump to the conclusion CLWA didn’t want anyone to know the bill was in the works, so it could sabotage the appellate court with an official pardon from Sacramento.
It was a twist of fate that Sen. Knight sits on the Senate Rules Committee and was in a position to hog-tie the bill. Had it not been for his insistence that the community weigh in on it, and for “opposition” CLWA board member Ed Dunn’s discovery of it— CLWA staffers evidently kept him in the dark, too— we may never have known about it.
