The issue that is holding up the 2001-20 state budget is a proposed increase in the sales tax.
When the governor first introduced his proposed budget in January, the state was swimming in an $8 billion surplus. Yet, the governor included in his proposal a quarter-cent increase in the sales tax. Then in May, shortly after the governor’s California Public Utilities Commission raised energy rates sky-high , and the state had spent nearly its entire surplus on energy, the governor again included the sales tax increase in his revised budget proposal. The increase remains in the current budget bill and for this reason Senate and Assembly Republicans rejected it when it has come up for a vote.
And we will continue to fight against this tax increase because not only is it unnecessary, but it also threatens our already faltering economy, and most importantly, it unfairly burdens the taxpayers of our state.
The quarter-cent sales tax was first enacted in 1991 when California was in a deep recession and needed to generate additional revenue for the state’s general fund. This $1.2 billion tax increase was promised to be temporary and, last year, California met the necessary conditions to repeal it.
Some argue that this increase would be insignificant and that with the slowing economy, the additional revenue is needed. They say that by eliminating this tax increase from the budget, vital programs such as education and law enforcement would have to be cut. They also argue that this is needed in order to afford the $2.2 billion reserve that is included in the budget.
The truth of the matter is that a quarter-cent increase in the sales tax is indeed significant. First of all, a sales tax increase forces taxpayers to shoulder yet another financial burden in addition to the dramatically higher energy rates they are paying. Secondly, an increase in the sales tax is the most regressive form of taxation, meaning it would most negatively affect the working families in our community. Additionally, the Pacific Research Institute says that an increase in the sales tax will cost California 85,000 jobs.
Lastly, this increase illustrates the shocking rate at which our government is growing. The ongoing cost of government is growing 5.5 percent over last year’s budget. With the current rate of inflation at less than 3 percent, this means government is growing at twice the rate of inflation! Even if we were to eliminate the sales tax increase from the budget, government would still grow at 5 percent! In fact, the non-partisan Legislative Analyst estimates that there will likely be between a $1.5 billion and $4 billion deficit by next year. So, not only is government growing at an astronomical rate, but budget planners haven’t even come up with a balanced budget!
And contrary to what some lawmakers would like you to believe, it is in fact possible to eliminate this increase in the sales tax without cutting existing programs. Right now, the budget includes in excess of $670 million in new programs, including special district projects. While funding district projects would be appropriate during good economic times, it is inappropriate at a time when the economy is slowing, the Legislature is struggling to find ways in which to maintain a suitable reserve and taxes are being raised.
In addition to these projects, there are $300 million in unfilled state positions. This equates to 10,000 positions for employees who don’t even exist! I believe taxpayers would prefer their money be used to go toward a tax cut rather than toward a slush fund for bureaucrats.
It is for these reasons that I do not support this budget. Obviously, the state is able to eliminate this tax— without cutting into education or other existing programs. And it disturbs me that while this budget continues to grow at twice the rate of inflation, the liberals in Sacramento are still arguing for increased spending and increased taxes.
Unless the Legislature produces a fair and balanced budget, one that does not include new taxes or wasteful spending, then I will not vote it.
Assemblyman George Runner is vice chair of the Assembly Budget Committee and represents the cities of Palmdale, Lancaster and Santa Clarita in the state Legislature.
