The words “Die Jews” were written on the man’s front door when he arrived home.
‘As a private property owner, you should not be compelled to provide the venue for someone else’s exercise of their free speech rights, unless your property is a ‘public gathering place.”’
It’s terrifying if you’re the owner of that particular door, and it’s appalling if you’re anyone else with a modicum of decency.
That has to be a hate crime, right? And even if you believe all crimes are hateful by nature, you’d agree that such an action must rise to the level of criminality, right?
There shouldn’t be any doubt, shouldn’t there?
Well, apparently, there has been some doubt in our legal system.
Fortunately, a recent court decision set the precedent that will form the basis for criminal charges if the culprits are caught in last week’s case of anti-Semitic vandalism of a home in Canyon Country.
Three times in approximately a one-week period, the same home was vandalized with vile anti-Semitic statements. The first time, a swastika and the phrase, “Die Jews,” were written in white crayon on the 41-year-old resident’s front door.
The subsequent incidents were even more hard-core , with the offensive phrases actually etched on the door.
One might assume all of this behavior is criminal, and at present, it is. But as recently as the past few years, the first incident— the one in which the vandal’s weapon of choice was a white crayon— might not have been a crime.
Under previous law, the courts had held that if a marring of a surface was easily removed, it would not be considered a crime. For example, if someone wrote an offensive statement on your driveway in chalk, it would not be considered vandalism because the chalk could easily be removed.
That was absurd. Our rights to property ought to also include the right to control messages— offensive or otherwise— that are displayed on our property. As a private property owner, you should not be compelled to provide the venue for someone else’s exercise of their free speech rights, unless your property is a “public gathering place.” Clearly, an individual’s home is not a public gathering place.
Thankfully, the rules have changed.
A December ruling in the California Court of Appeal’s 2nd District, coupled with newer language in the criminal code adopted by state legislators, made it a crime to engage in behavior such as the anti-Semitic white crayon graffiti.
In the appellate court ruling, it was determined that, even if a statement is “easily removable” it can still be considered vandalism, due largely to the new language in the criminal code.
In a previous case, chalk graffiti was found not to be criminal because the criminal code made it illegal to “deface with paint or any other liquid.” The defendant in that 1995 case argued, successfully, that the language of the criminal code made the act legal because chalk is not a liquid.
Neither, of course, is white crayon.
But since that 1995 case, the language of the code has been changed to delete the reference to liquid and to instead include the phrase, “defaces with graffiti or other inscribed material.”
As a result, the defendant in the December ruling lost the case because the court applied the new language: He had used a “Sharpie” pen to write graffiti on the projection booth window of a movie theater.
Yes, the message was “easily removable,” but it still constituted the defacing of another’s property, and by all means should be a criminal act. The appellate court ruled accordingly.
The broader definition is clearly the more sensible one, and it creates the possibility that, if the authorities catch the culprit who wrote “Die Jews” in crayon before converting the bigoted thoughts to etching, he or she will face not just two counts of vandalism, but three.
The entire situation, of course, is disturbing and thought-provoking : First and foremost, it is bothersome to know we have someone in our community’s midst who not only holds such beliefs, but also voices them by defacing others’ property.
And second, it is illustrative of the fact that even the most simple-minded criminal can violate our property rights and find loopholes in our laws if we are not careful.
