The House of Representatives’ passage of House bill 2505, “The Human Cloning Prohibition Act of 2001,” on Tuesday is cause for celebration. Several anti-cloning bills have been introduced in the House since April, some of which would have allowed cloning for the purpose of scientific research.
‘...The real issue is this: Is it right or wrong to ever destroy human life in order to satisfy the demands of another?’
But HR 2505 was the most restrictive in that it prohibits cloning of humans for any purpose and establishes harsh penalties for anyone who does. The Senate will soon be debating on a similar bill.
Striking at the heart of the stem cell controversy, the 249-178 victory to ban all human cloning comes at a significant time. The issue of stem cell research has divided conservatives right down the middle. Many who normally oppose the destruction of human life support harvesting stem cells from embryos left over from in-vitro fertilizations and slated for disposal. They reason that, rather than let these embryos go to waste, they should be put to good use in researching cures for any number of diseases. This logic is based on the argument that these embryos have not been placed in a womb and therefore cannot become human beings.
Despite initial concerns, these conservatives’ consciences have been placated with the assurance that sperm and egg donors will not be solicited and that these extra embryos will be the only resource for stem cell research. Eventually, however, the number of leftover embryos will not be sufficient to satisfy the demand for continuing research. Through cloning, endless supplies of human embryos would be available not only for harvesting stem cells, but also for other types of research as well, including organ and tissue harvesting and drug testing. HR 2505 prohibits cloning humans for any reason, including research or creating children.
The hot topic lately has been whether stem cell research should be federally funded. However, the real issue is this: Is it right or wrong to ever destroy a human life in order to satisfy the demands of another? If it is wrong, then it’s wrong whether funded by government or by private industry. If it is wrong, then it’s wrong whether that life was cloned or conceived. If it is wrong, then it is wrong whether that life is in a womb or a petri dish. The “Unborn Victims of Violence Act of 2001” defines an unborn child as “a member of the species homo sapiens at any stage of development who is carried in the womb,” suggesting that an embryo, even at its earliest stages of development, is a human life. We ought, therefore, to be extremely cautious in drawing a line between what life is worthy of protection and what life is expendable based solely on its location or origin.
Tuesday’s vote is just one step toward the ultimate goal of protecting all human life at every stage of development. The next step should be to end embryonic stem cell harvesting and to allow for federal funding of adult stem cell research, one alternative to using embryo stem cells in researching cures for a variety of diseases.
HR 2096, a bill now in the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, seems encouraging. It attempts to establish a national stem cell donor bank where stem cells can be collected from a variety of sources and stored for research purposes.
These sources will include “placentas, umbilical cord blood, and organs or tissues of living or deceased [persons] who [have] been born or of unborn human offspring who die of natural causes.”
Laurisa White Reyes is a Santa Clarita resident.
