At first glance, the stories appear to have little to do with each other except for the fact that they are both somehow related to the trash industry.
First, there is the months-running saga of the city of Santa Clarita’s trash franchises, discrepancies in the city’s waste diversion statistics, questions about the setting of local trash fees and, just last week, the City Council’s approval of an audit that, hopefully, will get to the bottom of it all.
And then, this week, there was the story of The Newhall Land and Farming Co. being sued by a jilted suitor who was irked when Newhall Land—Êthe Santa Clarita Valley’s largest developer and land owner— sold the Chiquita Canyon Landfill to someone else. That someone else, as it happens, is Republic Services, which also happens to be under the same ownership as Atlas Disposal, one of the three trash haulers to be investigated by the city of Santa Clarita’s trash audit.
The connection is just peripheral, right? The lawsuit story, really, in most ways, is not at all related to the stories about the city’s trash service other than the fact that trash is the common denominator. It’s really just a dispute between Newhall Land and Texas-based Landfill Holdings LLC, which alleges that Newhall Land acted in bad faith when it sold the landfill to Republic for $65 million as part of the settlement of another lawsuit. (The Texas company had offered $90 million for the dump.)
But there is one potentially important link between the two stories— a piece of information contained in the Landfill Holdings LLC lawsuit that appears to shed some light on the city trash franchise situation.
That piece of information is most succinctly stated as follows:
Eleven dollars.
That is, the lawsuit against Newhall Land, which otherwise has little or nothing to do with the city trash franchise situation, includes in its account of the dispute a reference to a purported disposal agreement in which Republic would be granted the right to dump at Chiquita for a tipping fee of $11 per ton.
The posted rate at Chiquita, called the “gate rate,” is $35 per ton, but waste haulers that deliver large amounts of trash to a dump typically negotiate their own deals for less than the gate rate.
Under its previous lease with Newhall Land, Republic (which operated Chiquita while the dump was under the developer’s ownership) was allowed to charge its affiliates, including Atlas, a rate equal to the lowest fee being charged to an unaffiliated hauler.
This is where it gets interesting. Local trash industry officials have declined to acknowledge their tipping fee agreements, although that information will certainly become public as a result of the city audit. However, if, for example, $11 is the lowest rate charged to a non-affiliated hauler, who might that hauler be?
Atlas controls 15 percent of the residential service under the city’s franchises, and Santa Clarita Disposal and Blue Barrel— both owned by trash giant Waste Management Inc. — control the remaining 85 percent. Ironically, Atlas offered last year to give the city a residential rate of $18.50 per month (versus the $22.13 each resident now pays) in exchange for increasing its piece of the pie from 15 percent to 50 percent.
When the city’s residential rates were set in 1996, the rates were calculated based on a tipping fee of $35 per ton— in other words, incorrectly supposing that all three haulers were paying the gate rate. Obviously, they are not, but just what they have been paying has not been made public. If the actual rate is approximately one-third of the gate rate— say, $11 per ton— the haulers in all likelihood have been making a far greater profit than was envisioned by the creation of the public trash franchises.
Of course, there’s nothing wrong with making a profit. And we would expect that the trash haulers, and other franchisees, would make a reasonable profit. But the city also has a fiduciary duty to get the best deal it can, and there comes a point in public franchises when a profit margin ceases to be “reasonable.”
It’s easy to see, therefore, that the story of the Landfill Holdings LLC lawsuit, while containing a certain amount of intrigue in its own right, raises some very interesting questions about an otherwise only peripherally related topic: The questions of just how much it costs the local haulers to do business, and whether the city could really get itself a better trash deal on behalf of taxpayers.
Fortunately, the city’s trash audit is likely to shed a great deal of light on these questions.
