The subject of vehicular police pursuits seems to be a source of unending attention, curiosity and discussion in our society. I would like to clarify why law enforcement agencies do the things they do when a person flees from them in a motor vehicle.
Pursuits are nothing new. People have been running from the law to avoid arrest and prosecution since there has been law. They have always used the means available at the time, such as feet, horses and now motor vehicles. Very few criminal incidents these days do not involve a motor vehicle. If an officer arrests or cites a person for some violation of law, that person should argue the case in court, not run. Running just makes the charges worse. When have we seen someone actually get away? If law enforcement officers were prohibited from pursuing suspected violators, people could simply run away, avoid prosecution, and continue their lawless behavior. Compliance with the law would become voluntary, not mandatory.
Translated into a highway situation, I can see these scenarios: You’ve been at your office’s annual holiday party, and you’ve consumed more alcoholic beverages than you should have. You’re doing your best to drive home, but not doing all that well. Well, there they are... the red and blue lights behind you, lighting up the whole inside of your car. Suddenly, you think about your arrest, jail, court, fines, DUI programs, loss of your driver’s license, lawyer fees, increased insurance, and damage to your career. You also realize that law enforcement officers in California have been prohibited from pursuing people in vehicles. Let’s see... If you stop, all that bad stuff happens. If you put the pedal to the metal, the officer simply goes away. What would you do? How about if you’re late for a very important flight at LAX, and you know the police can’t chase you? How would you drive? Would we really be safer if police could not pursue violators?
Some very real, emotional disasters can and occasionally do happen when people choose to flee in a vehicle. Whose fault is that? It is unquestionably the fault of the irresponsible driver who makes the choice to endanger every person on the road by fleeing in a car. There are times when a violator drives so recklessly that officers will abandon a pursuit. We actually encourage officers to do that for their own protection. Dropping out, however, does not protect the public from the fleeing person. If the police officer goes away, does the violator suddenly become a responsible, law-abiding citizen?
Will this person no longer be under the influence of alcohol or some other drug? Absolutely not. We’ve seen over and over that he or she will continue driving recklessly without the officers following, still creating a public danger.
Being involved in a pursuit is one of the scariest things an officer can do. It gets old real fast. Aside from the danger to yourself, you are witnessing very dangerous driving, and you are afraid someone is going to get hurt right in front of your eyes. We hand off pursuits to units in adjacent areas to keep the officers fresh, and have officers involved who are familiar with the area around the pursuit. In spite of what some people may think, it’s no fun. It is stressful, emotionally and physically draining. It is also our job to stop this person. Adding to the stress is the knowledge that pursuits are highly critiqued afterward by all levels of command. Law enforcement officers and agencies have the responsibility to operate within reason when pursuing someone in a car. The old “Keystone Cops” pursuit with hundreds of police cars running wild is unacceptable. Law enforcement agencies should have a written policy, train officers to follow it, enforce it, and complete this dangerous duty as safely as possible.
The airborne news media of today have actually helped with the issue of pursuit supervision and management. Many people believe law enforcement does not favor this scrutiny from the sky, and they think people start pursuits to get on television. I don’t agree with that, and I like the photographic coverage. In the past, as supervisors, we had to either try to catch up to a pursuit, or try to manage it by listening to the police radio. Now we can see it in real time and direct our officers with precision. The television tape also provides excellent evidence for prosecution. The only thing we don’t like is when commentators tell the world what we’re going to do before we do it, like deploying a spike strip. We’re working with them on that.
In pursuits and every other aspect of law enforcement, we are trying to do what we can to keep our communities as safe as possible. A vehicular pursuit is a great danger, caused by an out-of-control driver, but I don’t believe the danger is reduced by having the officers simply go away.
I’d like to hear what ideas you have. Please drop me a note at the California Highway Patrol, 28648 The Old Road, Valencia, 91355.
Pete Mader is captain of the CHP’s Newhall station.
