This is my column on the sign ordinance.
The sign ordinance, enacted 10 years ago by the SClarita City Council, becomes effective in November. While not to minimize the complexity of the ordinance, it has required new businesses since the date of enactment— and will require all businesses after the effective date— to utilize what most consider the more attractive, understated “tombstone” signs that came on the scene in the ’80s and ’90s and will outlaw the “anything goes” large garish signs of a bygone era.
I understand there are many businesses whose signs will not be in compliance with the ordinance when the effective date arrives. Because of the growth patterns in the SCV, many of the businesses that have come in after the effective date are larger, national companies who have cheerfully complied with the new sign ordinance. Add to that other small businesses that have also opened, and they have also complied without complaint.
That leaves some area businesses that existed prior to the enactment who are not in compliance. Due to the demographic shift in the population of the SCV in the last 10 years, most of these noncompliant businesses are “small.” Thus, the noncompliant businesses are whining that this is a just another case of a conspiracy of local government against the small business in favor of big business.
Now this is the opinion part of my column: Bull! I have driven all over the SCV. I have viewed the older retail corridors of Lyons Avenue, San Fernando Road and Soledad Canyon Road ( pre-ordinance areas) and the post-ordinance areas of the Valencia Marketplace, the McBean Parkway/Magic Mountain corridor, and the new shopping areas in Saugus on Bouquet Canyon and Canyon Country on Soledad Canyon Road and Sierra Highway. My conclusion. Small signs: Attractive. Big signs: Ugly.
So in my opinion the true issue is not big vs. small business, it is big, ugly signs vs. small, attractive signs.
Now this is the part of the column where I say why I think it is important that we make sure in the SCV that we frame the debate honestly rather than playing the big vs. small business trump card of emotion. Recent closures of businesses in the Lyons corridor especially have all been blamed on small, locally owned businesses being run off by the large national chains, and in at least one case there is probably merit to the argument. But it is called demagoguery in politics when an issue is framed in a manner emotional rather than factual, and it can cause poor decisions to be made.
Like not getting rid of big ugly signs.
Now this is the part of my column where I poorly tie the current events in the SCV into something from my childhood in the Midwest that only really has the remotest connection. In Bloomfield, Iowa, there was a sign controversy. Lowell Loper, local painter of signs with a quirky sense of humor, once set up a sign on an unrented space regarding “Historic Fort Bloomfield.” The sign showed a painting of a man in a Civil War-era military uniform and touted the many historical events that occurred at Fort Bloomfield, but mysteriously no address was given. That is because the whole thing was a hoax and joke thought up by the prankster Loper to fool travelers and new residents for a period of time.
Enter Ed Wegener, local insurance agent and historical stickler, who undertook a one-man campaign to have the sign removed. First shot: No address given. Loper fixed that by referring in the address to a location with three abandoned shacks that he used for storage as the site of the Fort.
Second shot. A grant from the federal government is used to tear down the three shacks. Now, no location. Loper solves this by putting a sign on the property that says that Fort Bloomfield was burned to the ground in the great federal grant uprising of 1972. Clever, huh?
Final shot. There never was a Fort Bloomfield. Loper finally succumbs to Wegener’s efforts. Wegener and Loper have spent so much time arguing about the issue, they have now become good friends and can be seen in local eateries often cracking each other up with their good humor. What does this have to do with the current issue in the SCV? Nothing, really. It is just a good story and it really was a controversy over a sign.
So as we continue to address issues as a community, let us always frame the issues correctly, and I reiterate, the issue of signs is not an issue of big vs. small business but big vs. small signs.
This concludes my column on the sign ordinance.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
