By the time you read this column it will have happened. Not to be outdone by parents from Plum Canyon and Mountainview, a group of parents from Helmers will have staged a presentation at a Hart Trustee meeting unparalleled in history since the Israelites marched around Jericho blowing their trumpets and pounding their shields. I am predicting that like the walls of that doomed city, the will of the Hart Trustees to do necessary boundary changes will also crumble, leaving us with an overutilized junior high at Arroyo Seco and an underutilized junior high facility at Sierra Vista. Will this be the end of the contest for loudest complaint?
There is in my mind a definite hierarchy of boundary complaints. The most legitimate is distance. It makes little sense from any point of view that students should pass each other every day in buses on Bouquet Canyon Road to go to two different junior high or high schools at opposite ends of one side of the SCV.
The arguments begin to get strained in the second level, which is the "We were here first!" argument. It goes something like this: "We bought our tract house in 1986 when everyone who had lived here since 1976 was complaining about development. Therefore, we 'own' the school that we would have attended at that time, so those 'new' people who have moved in since should go to what is viewed as a less desirable location."
This argument seems "fair," but it has one fatal flaw. We do not individually or as a group "own" a particular school. The schools are built by the district and are owned by all the taxpayers in the district. The trustees are charged with doing what is best for the entire district, and not just one particular area.
The next argument is what I call the "social" reasoning. "I just want my kids to continue to go to school with their friends." This is nice for children, but I wonder how many parents would encourage their kids to choose a college based on where all their friends are going. My personal experience was to suggest exactly the opposite. Sometimes a change can cause a shy child to suddenly bloom, since they are not carrying the baggage of several years of expected personality history with the same peer group. Also, it can be an important life lesson to learn how to interact and make friendships with new people. The other solution is we can send the whole elementary school to the junior high so everyone will stay together! No one seems to bring up this solution.
Arguments from this point on quickly degenerate into elitism. "I don't want my children to go to that school because they have lower test scores!" As some are aware the Saugus Union School District recently had their own boundary debates, which Nancy attended as an officer of our elementary PTA. At one meeting a parent stood up and showed an overhead bar chart which purported to prove the extreme disparity between average Stanford scores in one elementary school as compared with another where her child might be transferred! Believe it or not, the bar chart was in color!
Nancy asked me if I wanted to go to the next boundary meeting. I said no because sooner or later someone was going to show up with a Proxima and do a live Powerpoint show with sound effects and animation and I was liable to have a breakdown! Only in Santa Clarita would parents bring computer graphics to prove their point.
The final arguments just get down to plain meanness with "I don't want my kids to go to that part of town with those people." Those people are never specifically identified.
Let me share with you a little story. For a short period of time I practiced law in Central Iowa. One of my first assignments was the closing down of a financially struggling rural school district and consolidating it into a larger neighboring district. Emotions ran high and the 100 or so students displaced were extremely impacted. People promised that in a few years folks would no longer remember. Well folks, it took exactly six months.
The school that remained had an Olympic-sized swimming pool. The football team won the state championship that year. Everyone was so into where they were at, the emotion that had once seemed so strong just faded away. The same thing will happen here. Trust me!
In case any of you six regular readers are thinking I'm turning grumpy, there is one positive in all this. The crazed behavior does prove that Santa Clarita parents give a damn about their children's education. This parental involvement can only be good for whatever school the kids end up attending.
* * *
Tim Myers is a Santa Clarita resident and a frequent contributor to The Signal.
