You almost could have called it: In the end, after much legal wrangling, the disclosure was something of a ho-hum.
The William S. Hart Union High School District received a $1.25 million insurance settlement that, once the attorneys are done taking their cut, leaves the district approximately $810,000 toward repairing the auditorium at Hart High School.
Those are the basic elements of the settlement that had been kept secret since it was struck in November, but only became public this week when Superior Court Judge Haley Fromholtz ruled that, despite a confidentiality clause in the lawsuit settlement between the Hart district and its insurers, the public was entitled to receive the information.
The ruling came about as a result of a California Public Records Act request by The Signal, citing state law and legal precedents that make it clear that public agencies cannot enter into secret lawsuit settlements.
District officials eventually concurred — but feared releasing the terms of the settlement could expose the district to a breach of contract lawsuit. Thus, the ruling was sought from Fromholtz.
The auditorium, a valuable community resource, has been closed since it was damaged in the earthquake of Jan. 17, 1994. But the district office was asleep at the wheel and didn't immediately realize the auditorium was insured.
As a result, the district didn't file its insurance claim until more than a year and a half after the quake — so the claim was rejected by the insurer, who contended that the claim was not filed in a timely manner.
The Hart district sued, and now, five years after the quake, the outcome has been reached: The public nets $810,000 toward auditorium repairs, and as is often the case in situations like this, the only real winners are the attorneys.
The estimated cost of repairing the auditorium and the Hart High administration building is $2.7 million.
Thus comes to an end a situation that has been fraught with mismanagement on the part of the Hart High School District beginning with the early-morning earthquake of Jan. 17, 1994. The situation was bungled — badly — when no insurance claim was filed for more than 18 months after the quake, and it was bungled again when the Hart district, a public agency, in a monumental lapse of judgment, agreed to a secret lawsuit settlement.
Fortunately for the public interest, Judge Fromholtz agreed that the district erred — and that the community is entitled to know how its legal interests were represented.
It can only make you wonder, though: How much better would your interests have been represented if the district had handled the insurance claim properly in the first place?
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
