With any luck, Santa Clarita residents will finally be told Wednesday about the terms of a lawsuit settlement that has significant bearing on whether an important community resource — the auditorium at Hart High School — will be restored.
That's when Judge Haley Fromholz is scheduled to rule on the William S. Hart Union High School District's request to release the terms of the settlement of the district's lawsuit over earthquake insurance of the auditorium.
In the immediate aftermath of the Jan. 17, 1994 earthquake, the fact that the auditorium was insured somehow escaped the Hart district office. When it was later discovered that the quake-damaged auditorium was indeed covered, the district sued its broker and the insurance company for the funds that would be needed to reopen the auditorium. The lawsuit was filed more than two years after the earthquake.
Now, five years after the quake, the auditorium still awaits repairs while performing groups not only from Hart High but also throughout the community get by without a crucial venue.
Relief may be on the way, as the district and the defendants reached a settlement in November that reportedly pays the district more than $800,000. However, to date the public has not been informed of the terms of the settlement because the district agreed to a non-disclosure clause.
In other words, the Hart district — a public agency — agreed not to tell the public how it settled a dispute on the public's behalf.
In December, The Signal filed a request under the California Public Records Act demanding disclosure of the settlement agreement, as is required by law. But just when the district agreed to comply, the defendants in the case informed the district that it would be in violation of the settlement agreement if it went public with the settlement terms.
Fearing a breach-of-contract lawsuit, the district has gone back to court, seeking a judge's advice.
It's galling that the many parties involved — especially a public school district and its attorneys — ever thought such a confidential settlement would be OK in the first place. Even if they profess ignorance of the law, it's common knowledge that it's incumbent upon any public agency to do the public's business in public.
The Hart district, to its credit, has since tried to make the situation right. Its attorneys have researched the legal precedents, and cited them for the court in asking permission to release the settlement agreement to the community newspaper. The district's motion filed with the court appears to be a convincing argument for disclosure.
Hopefully, when that motion is considered in downtown Los Angeles Superior Court on Wednesday, the judge will rule in favor of keeping public matters public — despite the Hart district's ill-advised decision to go along with the insurance providers' request for secrecy.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
