The fire was intentionally set.
It started near the family Christmas tree, then the flames roared through the two-story home in Val Verde on New Year's Eve, sending the occupants scrambling for safety.
Two brothers — 17-year-old Sean Williams and 7-year-old Patrick Crawford — were severely burned as they escaped the home, and their aunt, Dawn Carter, 45, broke bones in both ankles and feet when she jumped from a second-floor window to flee the flames. Also in the home was Williams' ex-girlfriend, Patricia Lynn Martin, a 20-year-old who was burned and suffered smoke inhalation in the blaze.
Both of the boys died, succumbing to their injuries within days of the fire.
And the true picture of how and why this tragedy occurred may have died with them.
As Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department arson/explosives detectives investigated, they began to suspect that the fire was no accident. They pieced together information that led them to believe the fire wasn't merely a result of a Christmas tree that had been sitting too long. It had help.
But we can't tell you what that help was, or what might have motivated someone to start the fire on purpose. We can't tell you who started the fire, or how, or why — many of the basic ingredients for a news story. And we can't even tell you with certainty why no arson charges were filed, although it's not difficult to speculate.
It's not that there's any especially compelling moral reason for us to withhold this information. And it's not that we wouldn't share the information with you if we had it.
You see, we can't tell you, because the Sheriff's Department won't tell us.
And they don't have to.
This may come as a shock to some people, given the fact that the Sheriff's Department is a public agency, using your tax dollars to investigate possible crimes, and also given the fact that this particular intentionally set fire killed two boys who should have had many more years of life to live.
The arson detectives are rather cryptic about it, but they will tell us that only one person in the house was awake at the time the fire started, and that all of the doors were locked and the fire was deliberately set — but not with criminal intent.
No more details.
And under the California Public Records Act, they don't have to provide them.
You see, contrary to common perceptions, police reports aren't necessarily public information. The Public Records Act enumerates certain pieces of information that law enforcement authorities have to make public, and the courts have held that unless it's enumerated in the Public Records Act, the cops can keep it mum.
For instance, the law says police must release "the full name, current address and occupation of every individual arrested by the agency," along with other descriptive information on the suspect and the charges being sought.
Also, the law requires the authorities to release "the time, substance and location of all complaints or requests for assistance received by the agency," along with basic information on how the agency responded. There are a few other things, like rules governing the release of victims' names, but the bottom line is that the police don't have to release their full report — just those details that are specified by law.
As a media law attorney told us when we inquired about the possibility of gaining access to the investigation records of the New Year's Eve fire in Val Verde, "It's pretty grim."
And our prospects are worsened by the fact that, despite the allegedly intentional nature of the fire, there are no criminal charges and resultant court documents.
Usually, when a fire is intentionally set, and the detectives crack the case, you might expect arson charges to be filed, and as the case moves through the legal system, the details would come out and become part of the public record. But in this particular case, no such action is being taken.
We can only speculate, but it's not a matter of rocket science to come to the conclusion that, just maybe, no charges are being sought because the person who started the fire is deceased. And that the detectives concluded there was no criminal intent because the fire-starter was just a child, and perhaps didn't understand the fatal ramifications.
Of course, we can't say that for sure. We can't tell you how or why your detectives came to the conclusion they reached, and you can't evaluate the information for yourself to determine whether our law enforcement system did its job.
We can only speculate, because the Sheriff's Department won't share the information with you, despite the fact that this is a tragedy of significant public interest — the deaths of two boys — and the information was collected on your dime.
They don't have to tell you. That's the law, one that puts blinders on the watchdogs.
And there's something wrong with that.
* * *
Tim Whyte is managing editor of The Signal. His commentary appears on Sundays.
